Good Hair
Encyclopedia
Good Hair is a 2009 American comedy documentary film produced by Chris Rock Productions
and HBO Films
, starring and narrated by comedian
Chris Rock
. Premiering at the Sundance Film Festival
on January 18, 2009, Good Hair was released to select theaters in the United States
by Roadside Attractions
on October 9, 2009, opening across the country on October 23. The film focuses on African American women's hair, including the styling industry surrounding it, the acceptable look of African American women's hair in society, and the effects of both upon African American culture
.
Rock intended for the film to uphold a sense of seriousness, yet at the same time remain humorous. The movie features interviews from hair care industry businesspeople, stylists (Derek J, Jason Griggers and others) and their consumers, and celebrities such as Ice-T
, Nia Long
, Paul Mooney, T-Pain
, Raven-Symoné
, Maya Angelou
, KRS-One
, Salt-n-Pepa
, Kerry Washington
, Eve, Reverend Al Sharpton
, Andre Harrell
, Tracie Thoms
, Lauren London
, and Meagan Good
as they discuss their own experiences with their hair, and how black hair is perceived in the black community.
filmmaker Regina Kimbell filed a lawsuit in a Los Angeles
court against Chris Rock Productions, HBO Films, and Good Hair's American and international distributors. Kimbell charges that Rock's film is an illegal infringement of her similarly themed documentary My Nappy Roots: A Journey Through Black Hair-itage
, which she says she screened for Rock in 2007. While Kimbell sought an injunction against the wide release of Good Hair, a federal judge allowed Rock's film to be released as scheduled.
An example of this is seen in when examining the economy during the end of March 2009 when the unemployment rate doubled for married couples with children under the age of eighteen (Crawford, 6). During this time, white middle class women were observed trying to save money by frequenting salons less and purchasing home dye kits. In a study of one thousand women who visited hair salons to dye their hair, 15% claimed to purchase home dye-kits instead. There was also a report of a 20% increase in sales of Root Touch-Up by Clairol
. These are the type of products marketed for white women (Crawford, 7). Black women during the same period, however, were observed to be less affected by the falling economy. One possible reason for this could be because salons have a different role for African-American women than white women. They serve as a support system that enables the women a sense of normalcy in the poorer times (Crawford, 9). Society also creates a strong bond between a black woman’s identity and her hair.
).
Hair plays a very complex role for black women. Paulette Caldwell, a law professor writes, "I want to know my hair again, to own it, to delight in it again, to recall my earliest mirrored reflection when there was no beginning and I first knew that the person who laughed at me and cried with me and stuck out her tongue at me was me. I want to know my hair again, the way I knew it before I knew that my hair is me, before I lost the right to me, before I knew that the burden of beauty – or lack of it – for an entire race of people could be tied up with my hair and me” (Crawford, 9). Caldwell illustrates how her identity has become dependent on her hair and how she yearns to separate the two in order to once again have her own identity, one in which hair does not play a role. Because of how strongly society connects a black woman’s hair to her identity, it is understandable why black hair care has developed into a 9 billion dollar business.
Black women being defined by their hair is not a new concept in media. In Simi Bedford’s Yoruba Girl Dancing, Remi is a young girl who has beautiful hair that is well cared for. However, when Remi must go to England for boarding school, her grandmother wants her to cut off her hair because the Europeans won’t know what to do with it. Because Remi’s hair is cut off, part of her identity gets stripped from her when the Europeans cannot tell whether Remi is a boy or a girl (Crawford, 9).
In “Good Hair and Bad Hair: What this seems to say about us,” Gordon Allport
expresses his idea that groups who are oppressed internalize the ideologies of their oppressors. When it comes to the concept of what is defined as good hair and bad hair, he believes this is a representation of African Americans internalizing the concept from their oppressors, the slave masters. President Thomas Jefferson
proclaimed that there were two physical characteristics that separated whites and blacks, this was their skin tone and hair texture (Davis, 2). By having the idea that the natural African American hair needs to be straightened in order to be considered beautiful, Allport believes this represents the African Americans expressing their internalized ideologies of their oppressors.
. Women can expect to invest six to eight hours in the salon getting their hair braided into sections and then having tracks of hair attached onto the braids. After women get their weave, they regularly come back into the salon for hair washing
, conditioning
, and tightening. In the documentary, Rock learned that some women will spend upwards to $1000 for a weave and if they cannot afford it, they can put it on layaway.
The most desirable hair for weaves come from India. Much of this hair comes from a hair shaving process that is part a tonsuring ceremony performed at the Tirumala Venkateswara Temple
. Over 10 million people shave their heads because they believe that hair is a vanity and they give it up as a self-sacrificing act to the Hindu Gods. The hair collected from the temple is then sold around the world (The Oprah Winfrey Show).
However, in Hairtage: Women Writing Race in Children’s Literature, Dianne Johnson questions whether white people truly understand the concept of “good hair” and the meaning behind it. A scandal broke out when Ruth Sherman, a white schoolteacher in Brooklyn, shared the story Nappy Hair with her predominately black elementary school students. Many people were outraged by the cover of the book in which there was a caricature of a young black girl with a big Afro. This image combined with the usually negative term “nappy” upset the nearby residence enough that they wanted Sherman removed from the school. However, many of the students' parents supported Sherman (Johnson, 343).
African American hair that has not been treated with chemicals can be referred to as nappy, a negative connotation for their hair. This type of hair is looked down upon even within the African American communities. The term originates from a time when natural, coarse hair was considered ugly and undesirable.
within the work world where certain hairstyles are prohibited. These are the hairstyles that have historically been worn by black women, such as braids. In “Rogers v. American Airlines,” the court ruled in favor of the American Airline and allowed them to ban women wearing their hair in a braided fashion (Crawford, 10).
, Ice-T
, Raven-Symoné
, Dr. Maya Angelou
, Salt-n-Pepa
, Eve, Tracie Thoms
, and Reverend Al Sharpton
. They provide their own insights on “good hair” as well as their own personal stories in dealing with black hair. In addition to celebrity interviews, Rock also enters Santa Monica High School, hair salons and barbershops, and hair dealers to gain more insight from black teenagers, and men and women; he also visits Dudley Products, one of the few African-American-owned companies making hair products for the African-American community.
One of the interview subjects in Good Hair was actress Nia Long. She says, “There’s always this sort of pressure within the black community like, if you have good hair, you’re prettier or better than the brown-skinned girl that wears the Afro or the dreads or the natural hairstyle.” The question in the documentary that Rock brings up is the reasoning behind this. He questions why what is considered “beauty” is what doesn’t come naturally to African-American women. They are forced to endure sometimes-painful hair treatments in order to achieve this definition of beauty. If the treatments, such as hair relaxers, are done improperly, they can actually cause hair loss or burns on the scalp.
Rock also interview the Reverend Al Sharpton in the documentary. Sharpton says, “We wear our economic oppression on our heads.” He is referring to the fact that the multibillion-dollar hair business has shifted from African-American manufacturers to Asian manufacturers. Even though these products are targeted towards black consumers, Asians are the ones who are making the money from the products (Catsoulis).
, believes that it is a good thing that the subject is being talked about, but notes that the term “good hair” is no longer relevant to many young black women today. She believes that what is considered “good hair” is now what is considered healthy hair. She questions, “When will our hair cease to be political? Every other group of women can do what they want with their hair, and it’s not seen as making a statement. We’re over that, and we wish everyone else would be over it, too.” Ayana Byrd, an editor for Glamour magazine
, says, “The point is not to say hair is good or bad, it’s to say that once we work through the history behind our hair, we can get to a place where it can just be hair.” (Puente)
One example that Donaldson may be referring to is that Rock doesn’t address how Chinese men wore their hair in a certain way because it was what was considered the norm. In Johnson’s Hairtage: Women Writing Race in Children’s Literature, she describes how a long ponytail was sometimes worn by Chinese men simply for aesthetic reasons (Johnson, 341). Many critics feel that Rock’s documentary is very one sided and only introduces the idea of “good hair” and doesn’t examine all of its layers. It merely focuses on African Americans who, according to Johnson, want their hair to be similar to those in power, the white people (Johnson, 341).
Other critics say that Rock didn’t go far enough to provide context for the hair choices of women. One side argues that Rock ignores the on-going movement by black women to “go natural” and not conform to the European straight hair style, but Rock has no mention of this in the film. On the other hand, supporters of the film believe it is groundbreaking and argue that it is some of Rock’s best work.
Audience’s opinion of the documentary also varies. Some believe that the film is a great look into African-American culture while others are angry saying that it portrays black women as foolish and make them out to be laughingstock. Regardless of critic and audience opinion about the film, Rock, for the most part, is praised for at the very least bringing the subject into mainstream view. Many just wish that there was more context in the film.
Senior writer for Entertainment Weekly
, Alynda Wheat, is one of the people who give Rock credit for bringing attention to the subject, but refutes the idea that a woman who chooses to go to the hair salon has racial identity issues and want to be white. Wheat argues, “I have absolutely no desire to be white, and no one I know sits down in a stylist’s chair because they want to be white. If you’re going to educated people about something, it should be representative of a larger whole than just some actresses or one crazy shop where a weave costs $1,000.” In response to this, Rock states that he isn’t attacking black women for their hair choices, but rather the only thing he has a problem with is putting toxic relaxers on a toddler’s hair. He believes that all hair is good hair. Rock doesn’t believe that the documentary is exposing any secrets since all the products that are featured in the film can be found at any drug store. Likewise, anybody can walk down the street and take a look into a beauty salon and see the same hair practices being performed. Nothing is being done behind closed doors.
In the film, critics such as Zorianna Kit also believe that another weak part of was the Bronner Bros.
hair battle which was said to be a spectacle to watch, but is ultimately uninteresting and had little merit being in the film.
comes to Rock’s defense by saying, “This movie is not about the ‘natural’ part about hair. It’s the fact that we put in fake hair to make it look natural.”
In response to the lack of more context in the film, Rock says, “My first intent is always to make people laugh, but at the same time, put a little Oprah in there. Put a little information in there... a little positivity. It’s not important what’s on top of your head – it’s important what’s inside of your head. That is the theme of the movie.” Rock expresses that his first job is to be a comedian, and if people are able to learn more from the film, then that’s great (The Oprah Winfrey Show).
based on 78 reviews, with an average score of 7.4/10. Another review aggregation website, Metacritic
, based on 100 reviews from mainstream critics, gave the film an average score of 72/100 based on 27 reviews.
Chris Rock
Christopher Julius "Chris" Rock III is an American comedian, actor, screenwriter, television producer, film producer and director. He was voted in the US as the 5th greatest stand-up comedian of all time by Comedy Central...
and HBO Films
HBO Films
HBO Films is a division of the cable television network HBO that produces feature films and miniseries. While much of HBO Films' output is created directly for the television market, such as the film Witness Protection and the mini-series Band of Brothers, Pacific, Generation Kill and Angels in...
, starring and narrated by comedian
Comedian
A comedian or comic is a person who seeks to entertain an audience, primarily by making them laugh. This might be through jokes or amusing situations, or acting a fool, as in slapstick, or employing prop comedy...
Chris Rock
Chris Rock
Christopher Julius "Chris" Rock III is an American comedian, actor, screenwriter, television producer, film producer and director. He was voted in the US as the 5th greatest stand-up comedian of all time by Comedy Central...
. Premiering at the Sundance Film Festival
Sundance Film Festival
The Sundance Film Festival is a film festival that takes place annually in Utah, in the United States. It is the largest independent cinema festival in the United States. Held in January in Park City, Salt Lake City, and Ogden, as well as at the Sundance Resort, the festival is a showcase for new...
on January 18, 2009, Good Hair was released to select theaters in the United States
United States
The United States of America is a federal constitutional republic comprising fifty states and a federal district...
by Roadside Attractions
Roadside Attractions
Roadside Attractions is a US film distributor based in Los Angeles, California, founded in 2003, specializing largely in independent films.Lionsgate bought a partial stake in Roadside in 2007.-List of films released by Roadside Attractions:...
on October 9, 2009, opening across the country on October 23. The film focuses on African American women's hair, including the styling industry surrounding it, the acceptable look of African American women's hair in society, and the effects of both upon African American culture
African American culture
African-American culture, also known as black culture, in the United States refers to the cultural contributions of Americans of African descent to the culture of the United States, either as part of or distinct from American culture. The distinct identity of African-American culture is rooted in...
.
Overview
According to Rock, he was prompted to make the movie after his 5-year-old daughter Lola asked him, "Daddy, how come I don't have good hair?" During the film, Rock delves into the $9 billion black hair industry, and visits such places as beauty salons, barbershops, hair styling conventions and scientific laboratories (to learn the science behind chemical relaxers that straighten hair).Rock intended for the film to uphold a sense of seriousness, yet at the same time remain humorous. The movie features interviews from hair care industry businesspeople, stylists (Derek J, Jason Griggers and others) and their consumers, and celebrities such as Ice-T
ICE-T
* Ice-T, an American rapper and actor* ICE T , a tilting model of the German InterCityExpress series of high-speed trains...
, Nia Long
Nia Long
Nia Talita Long is an American actress and occasional music video director. She is best known for her roles in the television series The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air and Third Watch, and the films Boiler Room, Soul Food, Love Jones, The Best Man, Big Momma's House, Big Momma's House 2, Are We There...
, Paul Mooney, T-Pain
T-Pain
Faheem Rasheed Najm , better known by his stage name T-Pain, is an American singer-songwriter, rapper, record producer, and actor, currently signed to Young Money Entertainment. His debut album, Rappa Ternt Sanga, was released in 2005. In 2007, T-Pain released his second studio album Epiphany,...
, Raven-Symoné
Raven-Symoné
Raven-Symoné Christina Pearman , known professionally as Raven-Symoné , or simply Raven, is an American actress, singer, songwriter, comedian, dancer, television producer and model. Symoné launched her successful career in 1989 after appearing in The Cosby Show as Olivia...
, Maya Angelou
Maya Angelou
Maya Angelou is an American author and poet who has been called "America's most visible black female autobiographer" by scholar Joanne M. Braxton. She is best known for her series of six autobiographical volumes, which focus on her childhood and early adult experiences. The first and most highly...
, KRS-One
KRS-One
Lawrence Krisna Parker , better known by his stage names KRS-One , and Teacha, is an American rapper...
, Salt-n-Pepa
Salt-N-Pepa
Salt-N-Pepa is an American hip hop trio from Queens and Brooklyn, New York, that was formed in 1985. The group, consisting of Cheryl "Salt" Renee James, Sandra "Pepa" Denton, and Deidra "DJ Spinderella" Roper, was one of the first all-female rap crews....
, Kerry Washington
Kerry Washington
Kerry Washington is an American actress. She is known for her roles as Ray Charles's wife, Della Bea Robinson, in the film Ray , as Idi Amin's wife Kay in The Last King of Scotland, and as Alicia Masters, love interest of Ben Grimm, The Thing, in the live-action Fantastic Four films of 2005 and 2007...
, Eve, Reverend Al Sharpton
Al Sharpton
Alfred Charles "Al" Sharpton, Jr. is an American Baptist minister, civil rights activist, and television/radio talk show host. In 2004, he was a candidate for the Democratic nomination for the U.S. presidential election...
, Andre Harrell
Andre Harrell
Andre Harrell is founder of the now defunct record label, Uptown Records. Harrell also served as president/CEO of Motown Records. He was also the first half of the hip hop duo Dr. Jeckyll & Mr. Hyde.-Biography:...
, Tracie Thoms
Tracie Thoms
Tracie Nicole Thoms is an American television, film, and stage actress. She is best known for her roles in Rent, Cold Case, The Devil Wears Prada, Death Proof, and the short-lived Fox television series Wonderfalls....
, Lauren London
Lauren London
Lauren Nicole London is an American film and television actress, model, and occasional music video actress. Beginning her career in music videos and later transitioning into film and television, London earned recognition for her performances in the film ATL as well as the television shows 90210...
, and Meagan Good
Meagan Good
Meagan Monique Good is an American film and television actress and occasional film producer. Beginning her career at the age of four, Good has appeared in numerous commercials, television shows, feature films, and music videos....
as they discuss their own experiences with their hair, and how black hair is perceived in the black community.
Lawsuit from Regina Kimbell
On October 5, 2009, documentaryDocumentary
A documentary is a creative work of non-fiction, including:* Documentary film, including television* Radio documentary* Documentary photographyRelated terms include:...
filmmaker Regina Kimbell filed a lawsuit in a Los Angeles
Los Ángeles
Los Ángeles is the capital of the province of Biobío, in the commune of the same name, in Region VIII , in the center-south of Chile. It is located between the Laja and Biobío rivers. The population is 123,445 inhabitants...
court against Chris Rock Productions, HBO Films, and Good Hair's American and international distributors. Kimbell charges that Rock's film is an illegal infringement of her similarly themed documentary My Nappy Roots: A Journey Through Black Hair-itage
My Nappy Roots: A Journey Through Black Hair-itage
My Nappy Roots: A Journey Through Black Hair-itage is a 2005 American documentary film directed by Regina Kimbell.-Overview:This film explores the politics and history of African American hair and how the European ideal of beauty influenced black hair through modern history...
, which she says she screened for Rock in 2007. While Kimbell sought an injunction against the wide release of Good Hair, a federal judge allowed Rock's film to be released as scheduled.
Themes
The main focus in the film is the extreme lengths that black women are willing to go through in order to look a certain way. A common ideology in the American culture is that the straighter the hair, the prettier the woman. On the contrary, a woman wearing her hair naturally (with no chemical processing) is viewed as unkempt or unprofessional. Black women are willing to spend thousands of dollars on their hair, even if they cannot afford to do so.An example of this is seen in when examining the economy during the end of March 2009 when the unemployment rate doubled for married couples with children under the age of eighteen (Crawford, 6). During this time, white middle class women were observed trying to save money by frequenting salons less and purchasing home dye kits. In a study of one thousand women who visited hair salons to dye their hair, 15% claimed to purchase home dye-kits instead. There was also a report of a 20% increase in sales of Root Touch-Up by Clairol
Clairol
Clairol is a personal care products division of Procter & Gamble. The Clairol company was started in 1931 by Lawrence M. Gelb and wife, Joan, who named their enterprise after a hair-coloring preparation they found while traveling in France....
. These are the type of products marketed for white women (Crawford, 7). Black women during the same period, however, were observed to be less affected by the falling economy. One possible reason for this could be because salons have a different role for African-American women than white women. They serve as a support system that enables the women a sense of normalcy in the poorer times (Crawford, 9). Society also creates a strong bond between a black woman’s identity and her hair.
Identity
In Good Hair, Rock explains how a black woman’s hair can affect her daily activity (avoiding activities that may cause her hair to get wet and ruining her weave), wallets (weaves can cost thousands of dollars), and sex lives (men are forced to accept a "hands-off” policy). Rock explains that because a black woman’s hair is such an investment, men are often not allowed to touch it during sex. Rock says, "...You are conditioned not to even go there. When I was a dating guy, I dated women from different races. Anytime I was with an Asian or a Puerto Rican girl or a white girl, my hands would constantly be in their hair. Like my hands were thirsty.” The type of hairstyle that a black woman has can sometimes act as a predictor of what she is willing to do (The Oprah Winfrey ShowThe Oprah Winfrey Show
The Oprah Winfrey Show is an American syndicated talk show hosted and produced by its namesake Oprah Winfrey. It ran nationally for 25 seasons beginning in 1986, before concluding in 2011. It is the highest-rated talk show in American television history....
).
Hair plays a very complex role for black women. Paulette Caldwell, a law professor writes, "I want to know my hair again, to own it, to delight in it again, to recall my earliest mirrored reflection when there was no beginning and I first knew that the person who laughed at me and cried with me and stuck out her tongue at me was me. I want to know my hair again, the way I knew it before I knew that my hair is me, before I lost the right to me, before I knew that the burden of beauty – or lack of it – for an entire race of people could be tied up with my hair and me” (Crawford, 9). Caldwell illustrates how her identity has become dependent on her hair and how she yearns to separate the two in order to once again have her own identity, one in which hair does not play a role. Because of how strongly society connects a black woman’s hair to her identity, it is understandable why black hair care has developed into a 9 billion dollar business.
Black women being defined by their hair is not a new concept in media. In Simi Bedford’s Yoruba Girl Dancing, Remi is a young girl who has beautiful hair that is well cared for. However, when Remi must go to England for boarding school, her grandmother wants her to cut off her hair because the Europeans won’t know what to do with it. Because Remi’s hair is cut off, part of her identity gets stripped from her when the Europeans cannot tell whether Remi is a boy or a girl (Crawford, 9).
Conforming
In the documentary, Chris Rock raises the question of why black women go through such lengths when it comes to their hair. He makes viewers ponder if the reason for this is because black women want to look whiter. Rock is quoted as saying, “I knew women wanted to be beautiful, but I didn’t know the lengths they would go to, the time they would spend – and not complain about it. In fact, they appear to look forward to it” (Puente).In “Good Hair and Bad Hair: What this seems to say about us,” Gordon Allport
Gordon Allport
Gordon Willard Allport was an American psychologist. Allport was one of the first psychologists to focus on the study of the personality, and is often referred to as one of the founding figures of personality psychology...
expresses his idea that groups who are oppressed internalize the ideologies of their oppressors. When it comes to the concept of what is defined as good hair and bad hair, he believes this is a representation of African Americans internalizing the concept from their oppressors, the slave masters. President Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson was the principal author of the United States Declaration of Independence and the Statute of Virginia for Religious Freedom , the third President of the United States and founder of the University of Virginia...
proclaimed that there were two physical characteristics that separated whites and blacks, this was their skin tone and hair texture (Davis, 2). By having the idea that the natural African American hair needs to be straightened in order to be considered beautiful, Allport believes this represents the African Americans expressing their internalized ideologies of their oppressors.
Weaves
In the black hair business, the most profitable portion is the sale and maintenance of weavesHair weave
A hair weave is a very general term used to describe human or artificial hair used to alter one's natural hair appearance by adding additional hair to one's natural hair or by covering the natural hair altogether with human or synthetic hair pieces. The highest-quality extension hair is Indian...
. Women can expect to invest six to eight hours in the salon getting their hair braided into sections and then having tracks of hair attached onto the braids. After women get their weave, they regularly come back into the salon for hair washing
Hair washing
Hair washing is the cosmetic act of keeping hair clean by washing it with shampoo or other detergent products and water. Hair conditioner may also be used to improve hair's texture and manageability...
, conditioning
Hair conditioner
Hair conditioner is a hair care product that alters the texture and appearance of hair.-History:For centuries, natural oils have been used to condition human hair. These natural products are still used today, including essential oils such as tea tree oil and carrier oils such as jojoba oil...
, and tightening. In the documentary, Rock learned that some women will spend upwards to $1000 for a weave and if they cannot afford it, they can put it on layaway.
The most desirable hair for weaves come from India. Much of this hair comes from a hair shaving process that is part a tonsuring ceremony performed at the Tirumala Venkateswara Temple
Tirumala Venkateswara Temple
Tirumala Venkateswara Temple ), is a Hindu temple in the hill town of Tirumala, near Tirupati in the Chittoor district of Andhra Pradesh, South India. It is around from Chennai, from Hyderabad, and from Bangalore....
. Over 10 million people shave their heads because they believe that hair is a vanity and they give it up as a self-sacrificing act to the Hindu Gods. The hair collected from the temple is then sold around the world (The Oprah Winfrey Show).
Relaxers
Sometimes referred to as “creamy crack,” the hair relaxer is another integral product in black hair care. Women of other ethnicities usually use a perm as a way to curl their hair, but the opposite is true for black women who perm their hair to get it straight. Sodium hydroxide is the active ingredient in relaxers and it is strong enough to burn through a soda can if left in the solution for long enough, or a woman’s hair. This is why Rock pleads for parents to stop exposing their young children to relaxers. He argues that they shouldn’t have to worry about their hair until at least their teenage years (The Oprah Winfrey Show).White people dealing with black hair
Jason Griggers, a white hairstylist in the film, believes that Good Hair has helped to break barriers between whites and blacks and helped to spark dialog. When he started the competition, there were very few white people, but he says that it is much more integrated now. Griggers has been embraced in the black community as somebody who can work wonders on black hair.However, in Hairtage: Women Writing Race in Children’s Literature, Dianne Johnson questions whether white people truly understand the concept of “good hair” and the meaning behind it. A scandal broke out when Ruth Sherman, a white schoolteacher in Brooklyn, shared the story Nappy Hair with her predominately black elementary school students. Many people were outraged by the cover of the book in which there was a caricature of a young black girl with a big Afro. This image combined with the usually negative term “nappy” upset the nearby residence enough that they wanted Sherman removed from the school. However, many of the students' parents supported Sherman (Johnson, 343).
Natural hair viewed as undesirable
Natural African American hair has been viewed as undesirable for over one hundred years . In Hairtage: Women Writing Race in Children’s Literature, Dianne Johnson shares an advertisement from “The Gift of the Good Fairy” in the early 1900s that reads, “Once upon a time there lived a Good Fairy whose daily thoughts were of pretty little boys and girls and of beautiful women and handsome men and of how she might make beautiful those unfortunate ones whom nature had not given long, wavy hair and a smooth, lovely complexion” (Johnson, 338). This was an advertisement for Madam C.J. Walker’s hair products that were targeted towards black women. The advertisement depicts any hair that isn’t wavy and smooth as undesirable and something that the Good fairy has to fix. Over a hundred years later, black women still value straight hair.African American hair that has not been treated with chemicals can be referred to as nappy, a negative connotation for their hair. This type of hair is looked down upon even within the African American communities. The term originates from a time when natural, coarse hair was considered ugly and undesirable.
Discrimination
A black woman’s hair can also represent discriminationDiscrimination
Discrimination is the prejudicial treatment of an individual based on their membership in a certain group or category. It involves the actual behaviors towards groups such as excluding or restricting members of one group from opportunities that are available to another group. The term began to be...
within the work world where certain hairstyles are prohibited. These are the hairstyles that have historically been worn by black women, such as braids. In “Rogers v. American Airlines,” the court ruled in favor of the American Airline and allowed them to ban women wearing their hair in a braided fashion (Crawford, 10).
Interviews with celebrities
Throughout the documentary, many celebrities are featured such as Nia LongNia Long
Nia Talita Long is an American actress and occasional music video director. She is best known for her roles in the television series The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air and Third Watch, and the films Boiler Room, Soul Food, Love Jones, The Best Man, Big Momma's House, Big Momma's House 2, Are We There...
, Ice-T
ICE-T
* Ice-T, an American rapper and actor* ICE T , a tilting model of the German InterCityExpress series of high-speed trains...
, Raven-Symoné
Raven-Symoné
Raven-Symoné Christina Pearman , known professionally as Raven-Symoné , or simply Raven, is an American actress, singer, songwriter, comedian, dancer, television producer and model. Symoné launched her successful career in 1989 after appearing in The Cosby Show as Olivia...
, Dr. Maya Angelou
Maya Angelou
Maya Angelou is an American author and poet who has been called "America's most visible black female autobiographer" by scholar Joanne M. Braxton. She is best known for her series of six autobiographical volumes, which focus on her childhood and early adult experiences. The first and most highly...
, Salt-n-Pepa
Salt-N-Pepa
Salt-N-Pepa is an American hip hop trio from Queens and Brooklyn, New York, that was formed in 1985. The group, consisting of Cheryl "Salt" Renee James, Sandra "Pepa" Denton, and Deidra "DJ Spinderella" Roper, was one of the first all-female rap crews....
, Eve, Tracie Thoms
Tracie Thoms
Tracie Nicole Thoms is an American television, film, and stage actress. She is best known for her roles in Rent, Cold Case, The Devil Wears Prada, Death Proof, and the short-lived Fox television series Wonderfalls....
, and Reverend Al Sharpton
Al Sharpton
Alfred Charles "Al" Sharpton, Jr. is an American Baptist minister, civil rights activist, and television/radio talk show host. In 2004, he was a candidate for the Democratic nomination for the U.S. presidential election...
. They provide their own insights on “good hair” as well as their own personal stories in dealing with black hair. In addition to celebrity interviews, Rock also enters Santa Monica High School, hair salons and barbershops, and hair dealers to gain more insight from black teenagers, and men and women; he also visits Dudley Products, one of the few African-American-owned companies making hair products for the African-American community.
One of the interview subjects in Good Hair was actress Nia Long. She says, “There’s always this sort of pressure within the black community like, if you have good hair, you’re prettier or better than the brown-skinned girl that wears the Afro or the dreads or the natural hairstyle.” The question in the documentary that Rock brings up is the reasoning behind this. He questions why what is considered “beauty” is what doesn’t come naturally to African-American women. They are forced to endure sometimes-painful hair treatments in order to achieve this definition of beauty. If the treatments, such as hair relaxers, are done improperly, they can actually cause hair loss or burns on the scalp.
Rock also interview the Reverend Al Sharpton in the documentary. Sharpton says, “We wear our economic oppression on our heads.” He is referring to the fact that the multibillion-dollar hair business has shifted from African-American manufacturers to Asian manufacturers. Even though these products are targeted towards black consumers, Asians are the ones who are making the money from the products (Catsoulis).
Oprah
Rock has been featured on Oprah twice for his work with Good Hair. The first time Rock was there to promote the film and the second time he was there to discuss the reactions after the film’s release. During his second appearance, a roundtable of black women was gathered to discuss hair and self-esteem. Mikki Taylor, beauty and cover editor for Essence magazineEssence (magazine)
Essence is a monthly magazine for African-American women between the ages of 18 and 49. The magazine covers fashion, lifestyle and beauty with an intimate girlfriend-to-girlfriend tone.-History:...
, believes that it is a good thing that the subject is being talked about, but notes that the term “good hair” is no longer relevant to many young black women today. She believes that what is considered “good hair” is now what is considered healthy hair. She questions, “When will our hair cease to be political? Every other group of women can do what they want with their hair, and it’s not seen as making a statement. We’re over that, and we wish everyone else would be over it, too.” Ayana Byrd, an editor for Glamour magazine
Glamour (magazine)
Glamour is a women's magazine published by Condé Nast Publications. Founded in 1939 in the United States, it was originally called Glamour of Hollywood....
, says, “The point is not to say hair is good or bad, it’s to say that once we work through the history behind our hair, we can get to a place where it can just be hair.” (Puente)
Criticism
The film exposes the pressures that African American women feel to conform to the mainstream definition of beauty. Some people were upset with the documentary exposing the extreme lengths that black women go through to obtain the “perfect” hairstyle. Chris-Tia Donaldson, a Chicago lawyer says, “You’re putting all of our business in the street. Why are you pulling the curtain back?” (Puente). She believes the documentary does not dig further into the root of the problem by saying, “The deeper issue continues to be glossed over, which is why do minority women in America feel so much pressure to conform to a mainstream standard of beauty that is hard to attain?” She believes that the documentary only touches on a superficial level of the problem while ignoring all other minorities who try to alter their appearance in striving for the mainstream definition of beauty.One example that Donaldson may be referring to is that Rock doesn’t address how Chinese men wore their hair in a certain way because it was what was considered the norm. In Johnson’s Hairtage: Women Writing Race in Children’s Literature, she describes how a long ponytail was sometimes worn by Chinese men simply for aesthetic reasons (Johnson, 341). Many critics feel that Rock’s documentary is very one sided and only introduces the idea of “good hair” and doesn’t examine all of its layers. It merely focuses on African Americans who, according to Johnson, want their hair to be similar to those in power, the white people (Johnson, 341).
Other critics say that Rock didn’t go far enough to provide context for the hair choices of women. One side argues that Rock ignores the on-going movement by black women to “go natural” and not conform to the European straight hair style, but Rock has no mention of this in the film. On the other hand, supporters of the film believe it is groundbreaking and argue that it is some of Rock’s best work.
Audience’s opinion of the documentary also varies. Some believe that the film is a great look into African-American culture while others are angry saying that it portrays black women as foolish and make them out to be laughingstock. Regardless of critic and audience opinion about the film, Rock, for the most part, is praised for at the very least bringing the subject into mainstream view. Many just wish that there was more context in the film.
Senior writer for Entertainment Weekly
Entertainment Weekly
Entertainment Weekly is an American magazine, published by the Time division of Time Warner, that covers film, television, music, broadway theatre, books and popular culture...
, Alynda Wheat, is one of the people who give Rock credit for bringing attention to the subject, but refutes the idea that a woman who chooses to go to the hair salon has racial identity issues and want to be white. Wheat argues, “I have absolutely no desire to be white, and no one I know sits down in a stylist’s chair because they want to be white. If you’re going to educated people about something, it should be representative of a larger whole than just some actresses or one crazy shop where a weave costs $1,000.” In response to this, Rock states that he isn’t attacking black women for their hair choices, but rather the only thing he has a problem with is putting toxic relaxers on a toddler’s hair. He believes that all hair is good hair. Rock doesn’t believe that the documentary is exposing any secrets since all the products that are featured in the film can be found at any drug store. Likewise, anybody can walk down the street and take a look into a beauty salon and see the same hair practices being performed. Nothing is being done behind closed doors.
In the film, critics such as Zorianna Kit also believe that another weak part of was the Bronner Bros.
Bronner Bros.
The Bronner Bros. Enterprise is one of the largest private African-American hair and skin care producers in the United States. Founded in 1947 by brothers Dr. Nathaniel H. Bronner, Sr. and Arthur E. Bronner, Sr., Bronner Bros. has over 300 full-time and part-time staff members...
hair battle which was said to be a spectacle to watch, but is ultimately uninteresting and had little merit being in the film.
Response to criticism
Rock’s response to critics who believed his film was one-sided and didn’t focus on black women who chose to wear their hair naturally was, “That would be like doing a story on ‘Hey, there’s no toxins in the water. Or, ‘Let’s do a story on people who didn’t get murdered yesterday.” Rock wanted to depict the extreme lengths that black women go through in order to obtain “good hair,” not the lack of extreme lengths that black women go through. Actress Raven-SymonéRaven-Symoné
Raven-Symoné Christina Pearman , known professionally as Raven-Symoné , or simply Raven, is an American actress, singer, songwriter, comedian, dancer, television producer and model. Symoné launched her successful career in 1989 after appearing in The Cosby Show as Olivia...
comes to Rock’s defense by saying, “This movie is not about the ‘natural’ part about hair. It’s the fact that we put in fake hair to make it look natural.”
In response to the lack of more context in the film, Rock says, “My first intent is always to make people laugh, but at the same time, put a little Oprah in there. Put a little information in there... a little positivity. It’s not important what’s on top of your head – it’s important what’s inside of your head. That is the theme of the movie.” Rock expresses that his first job is to be a comedian, and if people are able to learn more from the film, then that’s great (The Oprah Winfrey Show).
Critical
The film has met with acclaim from critics. Good Hair currently holds a 95% "certified fresh" rating on aggregate review website Rotten TomatoesRotten Tomatoes
Rotten Tomatoes is a website devoted to reviews, information, and news of films—widely known as a film review aggregator. Its name derives from the cliché of audiences throwing tomatoes and other vegetables at a poor stage performance...
based on 78 reviews, with an average score of 7.4/10. Another review aggregation website, Metacritic
Metacritic
Metacritic.com is a website that collates reviews of music albums, games, movies, TV shows and DVDs. For each product, a numerical score from each review is obtained and the total is averaged. An excerpt of each review is provided along with a hyperlink to the source. Three colour codes of Green,...
, based on 100 reviews from mainstream critics, gave the film an average score of 72/100 based on 27 reviews.