Minimal residual disease
Encyclopedia
Minimal residual disease (MRD) is the name given, to small numbers of leukaemic cells that remain in the patient during treatment, or after treatment when the patient is in remission (no symptoms or signs of disease). It is the major cause of relapse in cancer and leukaemia. Up until a decade ago none of the tests used to assess/detect cancer, were sensitive enough to detect MRD. Now, however, very sensitive molecular biology tests are available - based on DNA
, RNA
or Proteins - and these can measure minute levels of cancer cells in tissue samples, sometimes as low as 1 cancer cell in million normal cells.
In cancer treatment, particularly leukaemia, MRD testing has several important roles: determining whether treatment has eradicated the cancer or whether traces remain, comparing the efficacy of different treatments, monitoring patient remission status and recurrence of the leukaemia or cancer and choosing the treatment that will best meet those needs (personalization of treatment)
The tests are not simple, are often part of research or trials, and some have been accepted for routine clinical use.
, and childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (the commonest childhood cancer). What follows, is a very simple discussion, of how leukaemia arises, how MRD arises, and why MRD is important.
Leukaemia is a cancer of white blood cells. The tissue mainly affected is bone marrow.
For most human leukaemias, the cause is not known. Risk factors can include chemicals, X-rays, but for most cases, it's not possible to identify the cause.
The disease is due to a defect in genes.
Leukaemia starts when one cell in the body acquires such a change in a key gene. That cell starts to grow and divide.
The body normally has a range of different types of blood cells, in standard proportions. In leukaemia, one type starts growing and dividing without stopping, and eventually large numbers of these cells accumulate. If the cells affected were gut cells or skin, a solid tumor would result. Leukaemic cells grow and divide without regulation, and crowd out the normal variety of blood cells.
It is only when the disease is advanced that people notice symptoms. By the time someone recognises symptoms of leukaemia, they have very many leukaemic cells in their body - 1 kg or 1,000,000,000,000 leukaemic cells.
If doctors take a sample of bone marrow , they can see these leukaemic cells under a microscope. Leukaemic cells look like normal immature blood cells, and healthy marrow is often 1-2% immature ('blast') cells. However, in leukaemia, there are abnormally high numbers of immature cells, making up 40-90% of marrow. Additional examination of the bone marrow by tests including flow cytometry and FISH are necessary to diagnose the specific malignancy.
The initial 5 weeks of treatment kill most leukaemic cells, and the marrow begins to recover. Immature white blood cells maybe be present in the patient, but these blasts are not always malignant cells.
In most cases a few leukaemic cells survive this treatment, and persist in the marrow for months or years. Approximately 0.001% of those present at the start survive cancer treatment. There is no way to identify them by looking at the marrow using only a microscope. DNA based tests and immunology tests are needed to identify the cells.
About 30 years ago leukaemia was universally fatal. The first treatments treated patients for a few weeks (not months or years as at present), producing remission, but nearly all patients relapsed after a few weeks or months. It is now known that minimal residual disease can regrow once treatment was stopped. Genetic tests can confirm the leukaemic cells at relapse are descendants of those present when the disease first appeared.
Relapse is a problem in leukaemia, and the doctors aim to prevent relapse rather than treat it. Currently, most children do not relapse - the disease is "cured" at first attempt. If the disease relapses, it is usually more resistant to treatment than when first diagnosed. If one gives the same drugs again, the disease may not respond as well. Patients who have relapsed once are at high risk of relapse in the future.
Tests which uncover minimal residual disease (one cancerous cell in a population of one million normal cells) are helpful for directing treatment and preventing relapse. A single remaining leukaemic cell can be fatal, as malignant cells divide without control. Conditioning regiments can continue as long as the patient is healthy enough to sustain damage by cytotoxic treatments.
Most research on MRD was done on leukaemia and lymphoma
s. Researchers hope that the discoveries made can be applied to understand and treat other cancers.
, a highly sensitive technique that underpins much of molecular biology. The DNA sequence chosen, may contribute to the genesis of the leukaemia, or may simply be linked to it.
The markers used for DNA based testing are often chromosomal translocation
s such as t(14;18) involving BCL2 and t(11;14) involving BCL1 (CCND1). Other genes utilized for MRD detection include microsatellites, immunoglobulin and T cell receptor
.
translocation may occur over a large length of the chromosome which makes DNA based testing difficult and inefficient. However, RNA is a much less stable target for diagnostics than DNA and requires careful handling and processing.
The markers used for RNA based testing are almost exclusively chromosomal translocations such as t(9;22) BCR-ABL, t(15;17) PML-RARA
and t(12;21) ETV6
-RUNX1 (TEL-AML1).
Both the DNA and RNA based tests require that a pathologist examine the bone marrow to determine which leukaemic specific sequence to target. Once the target is determined, a samples of blood or bone marrow is obtained, nucleic acid is extracted, and the sample analyzed for the leukaemic sequence. These tests are very specific, and detect leukaemic cells at levels down to 1 cell in a million, though the limit typically achieved is 1 in 10,000 to 1 in 100,000 cells. For comparison, the limit of what one can detect using traditional morphologic examinations using a microscope is about 1 cell in 100.
. The limit of detection of immunological tests is generally about 1 in 10,000 cells and cannot be used on leukaemias that don’t have an identifiable and stable leukaemic phenotype.
t(9;22) BCR-ABL, t(12;21) ETV6-RUNX1 (TEL-AML1), Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes
Uses: Chromosomal translocation MRD detection is widely used as a standard clinical practice. Patient specific assays are gaining acceptance but are still generally only used in research protocols.
t(15;17) PML-RARA, t(8;21) AML1-RUNX1
T1 (AML-ETO), inv(16)
Uses: Chromosomal translocation MRD detection widely used as a standard clinical practice.
Cell surface proteins, Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes
Uses: Immunological methods are gaining wider use as more advanced flow cytometers are utilized for clinical testing. Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Chronic myelogenous leukemia
Target:
t(9;22) BCR-ABL
Uses: MRD detection of the t(9;22) is considered standard of care for all patients with CML and is extremely valuable for patients being treated with imatinib mesylate (Gleevec/Glivec).
Follicular lymphoma
Targets:
t(14;18) IgH/BCL2, Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes.
Uses: The t(14;18) is regularly used for MRD detection. Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Mantle cell lymphoma
Targets:
t(11;14) IgH/CCND1 (IgH/BCL1), Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes
Uses: The t(11;14) is regularly used for MRD detection, but the assay can only reliably detect 40-60% of the t(11;14) translocations. Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Multiple myeloma
Targets:
M-protein levels in blood, Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes (high levels of somatic hypermutation
often prevent this assay from reliably working).
Uses: M-protein level in the blood is standard of care and is used for almost all patients with multiple myeloma.
Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
and neuroblastoma
has been performed. These assays have been used to sample lymph nodes and blood for residual or metastatic tumor cells. Applicable targets for MRD detection have been more difficult to determine in solid tumors and the use of MRD in solid tumors is much less advanced than the use in leukemia and lymphoma.
When past patients were studied: Patients with high levels at this stage - here "high" means often leukaemia more than 1 cell in 1000, were at risk of relapse. Patients with levels below 1 in 100,000 were very unlikely to relapse. Those in between, some relapsed. This led to the idea that MRD testing could predict outcome, and this has now been shown. The next step is whether, having identified a patient whom standard treatment leaves at high risk - there are different treatments they could be offered, to lower that risk. Several clinical trials are investigating this.
Other research groups have looked at other times in treatment -e.g. 3 months, 6 months, 1 year, or end of current treatment (2 years) and these can predict outcome also.
There are also a few scientific studies, showing that level of MRD after bone marrow transplant, shows the risk of relapsing.
For instance, the initial 5 week induction treatment, might rapidly clear disease for some patients. For others, the same treatment might leave significant amounts of disease . Measuring MRD level, helps doctors decide which patients need what. In other words, it identifies patients individual risk of relapse, and can theoretically allow them to receive just enough treatment to prevent it.
Without MRD information, doctors can do nothing but give the same treatment to all patients. They know that this will be inadequate for some and excessive for others, but there is little else they can do, as it is not possible to tell who needs what. Identification of risk factors, to help individualise treatment, is a big field in medicine.
It seems a sensible idea to aim to reduce or eradicate MRD. What is needed, is evidence on which is the best method, and how well it works. This is emerging. Treatments which specifically target MRD can include.
(a) intensive conventional treatment with more drugs, or a different combination of drugs
(b) stem cell transplant, e.g. marrow transplant. This allows more intensive chemotherapy to be given, and in addition the transplanted bone marrow may help eradicate the minimal residual disease
(c) immunotherapy
(d) monitor the patient carefully for early signs of relapse. This is an area of active research in several countries.
(e) treatment with monoclonal antibodies which target cancer cells
(f) cancer vaccines
Currently most MRD testing - in leukaemia research - is done during clinical trials, and would be funded as part of that trial, for patients enrolled on the trial. The tests are specialised, so samples are usually sent to a central reference laboratory in each region or country. The tests are not done in most routine diagnostic labs, as they tend to be complex, and also would be used relatively infrequently.
The consequence: unless a patient is enrolled on a trial which requires the test - clinicians tend to be somewhat cautious about requesting it, and cautious about interpreting the results. This is likely to change in future, as tests become more routine.
DNA
Deoxyribonucleic acid is a nucleic acid that contains the genetic instructions used in the development and functioning of all known living organisms . The DNA segments that carry this genetic information are called genes, but other DNA sequences have structural purposes, or are involved in...
, RNA
RNA
Ribonucleic acid , or RNA, is one of the three major macromolecules that are essential for all known forms of life....
or Proteins - and these can measure minute levels of cancer cells in tissue samples, sometimes as low as 1 cancer cell in million normal cells.
In cancer treatment, particularly leukaemia, MRD testing has several important roles: determining whether treatment has eradicated the cancer or whether traces remain, comparing the efficacy of different treatments, monitoring patient remission status and recurrence of the leukaemia or cancer and choosing the treatment that will best meet those needs (personalization of treatment)
The tests are not simple, are often part of research or trials, and some have been accepted for routine clinical use.
Background: the problem of minimal residual disease (MRD)
Most research on MRD has been done on leukaemia. Mainly two types: adult chronic myeloid leukaemiaChronic myelogenous leukemia
Chronic myelogenous leukemia , also known as chronic granulocytic leukemia , is a cancer of the white blood cells. It is a form of leukemia characterized by the increased and unregulated growth of predominantly myeloid cells in the bone marrow and the accumulation of these cells in the blood...
, and childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (the commonest childhood cancer). What follows, is a very simple discussion, of how leukaemia arises, how MRD arises, and why MRD is important.
Leukaemia is a cancer of white blood cells. The tissue mainly affected is bone marrow.
For most human leukaemias, the cause is not known. Risk factors can include chemicals, X-rays, but for most cases, it's not possible to identify the cause.
The disease is due to a defect in genes.
Leukaemia starts when one cell in the body acquires such a change in a key gene. That cell starts to grow and divide.
The body normally has a range of different types of blood cells, in standard proportions. In leukaemia, one type starts growing and dividing without stopping, and eventually large numbers of these cells accumulate. If the cells affected were gut cells or skin, a solid tumor would result. Leukaemic cells grow and divide without regulation, and crowd out the normal variety of blood cells.
It is only when the disease is advanced that people notice symptoms. By the time someone recognises symptoms of leukaemia, they have very many leukaemic cells in their body - 1 kg or 1,000,000,000,000 leukaemic cells.
If doctors take a sample of bone marrow , they can see these leukaemic cells under a microscope. Leukaemic cells look like normal immature blood cells, and healthy marrow is often 1-2% immature ('blast') cells. However, in leukaemia, there are abnormally high numbers of immature cells, making up 40-90% of marrow. Additional examination of the bone marrow by tests including flow cytometry and FISH are necessary to diagnose the specific malignancy.
The initial 5 weeks of treatment kill most leukaemic cells, and the marrow begins to recover. Immature white blood cells maybe be present in the patient, but these blasts are not always malignant cells.
In most cases a few leukaemic cells survive this treatment, and persist in the marrow for months or years. Approximately 0.001% of those present at the start survive cancer treatment. There is no way to identify them by looking at the marrow using only a microscope. DNA based tests and immunology tests are needed to identify the cells.
About 30 years ago leukaemia was universally fatal. The first treatments treated patients for a few weeks (not months or years as at present), producing remission, but nearly all patients relapsed after a few weeks or months. It is now known that minimal residual disease can regrow once treatment was stopped. Genetic tests can confirm the leukaemic cells at relapse are descendants of those present when the disease first appeared.
Relapse is a problem in leukaemia, and the doctors aim to prevent relapse rather than treat it. Currently, most children do not relapse - the disease is "cured" at first attempt. If the disease relapses, it is usually more resistant to treatment than when first diagnosed. If one gives the same drugs again, the disease may not respond as well. Patients who have relapsed once are at high risk of relapse in the future.
Tests which uncover minimal residual disease (one cancerous cell in a population of one million normal cells) are helpful for directing treatment and preventing relapse. A single remaining leukaemic cell can be fatal, as malignant cells divide without control. Conditioning regiments can continue as long as the patient is healthy enough to sustain damage by cytotoxic treatments.
Most research on MRD was done on leukaemia and lymphoma
Lymphoma
Lymphoma is a cancer in the lymphatic cells of the immune system. Typically, lymphomas present as a solid tumor of lymphoid cells. Treatment might involve chemotherapy and in some cases radiotherapy and/or bone marrow transplantation, and can be curable depending on the histology, type, and stage...
s. Researchers hope that the discoveries made can be applied to understand and treat other cancers.
DNA based tests
These are based on detecting a leukaemic specific DNA sequence. Generally this is achieved through the use of the polymerase chain reactionPolymerase chain reaction
The polymerase chain reaction is a scientific technique in molecular biology to amplify a single or a few copies of a piece of DNA across several orders of magnitude, generating thousands to millions of copies of a particular DNA sequence....
, a highly sensitive technique that underpins much of molecular biology. The DNA sequence chosen, may contribute to the genesis of the leukaemia, or may simply be linked to it.
The markers used for DNA based testing are often chromosomal translocation
Chromosomal translocation
In genetics, a chromosome translocation is a chromosome abnormality caused by rearrangement of parts between nonhomologous chromosomes. A gene fusion may be created when the translocation joins two otherwise separated genes, the occurrence of which is common in cancer. It is detected on...
s such as t(14;18) involving BCL2 and t(11;14) involving BCL1 (CCND1). Other genes utilized for MRD detection include microsatellites, immunoglobulin and T cell receptor
T cell receptor
The T cell receptor or TCR is a molecule found on the surface of T lymphocytes that is responsible for recognizing antigens bound to major histocompatibility complex molecules...
.
RNA based tests
These are based on detecting a leukemic specific RNA sequence. Generally this is achieved through the use of reverse transcription of the RNA followed by polymerase chain reaction. RNA based tests are normally utilized when a DNA test is impractical. For example, the t(9;22) BCR-ABLPhiladelphia chromosome
Philadelphia chromosome or Philadelphia translocation is a specific chromosomal abnormality that is associated with chronic myelogenous leukemia . It is the result of a reciprocal translocation between chromosome 9 and 22, and is specifically designated t...
translocation may occur over a large length of the chromosome which makes DNA based testing difficult and inefficient. However, RNA is a much less stable target for diagnostics than DNA and requires careful handling and processing.
The markers used for RNA based testing are almost exclusively chromosomal translocations such as t(9;22) BCR-ABL, t(15;17) PML-RARA
Acute promyelocytic leukemia
Acute promyelocytic leukemia is a subtype of acute myelogenous leukemia , a cancer of the blood and bone marrow. It is also known as acute progranulocytic leukemia; APL; AML with t, PML-RARA and variants; FAB subtype M3 and M3 variant.In APL, there is an abnormal accumulation of immature...
and t(12;21) ETV6
ETV6
ETV6 is an oncogene.-Interactions:ETV6 has been shown to interact with Grb2, FLI1 and HTATIP.-See also:* TEL-JAK2Mouse Mutant Alleles for Etv6 Marker Symbol for Mouse Gene. This symbol is assigned to the genomic locus by the...
-RUNX1 (TEL-AML1).
Patient specific testing
Patient specific MRD detection using immunoglobulin (IG) or T cell receptors (TCR) is gaining popularity as a way of measuring MRD in leukemias that do not contain a chromosomal translocation or other leukemic specific marker. In this case the leukemic specific IG or TCR clone is amplified using PCR and the variable region of the IG or TCR is sequenced. From this sequence PCR primers are designed that will only amplify the specific leukemic clone from the patient.Both the DNA and RNA based tests require that a pathologist examine the bone marrow to determine which leukaemic specific sequence to target. Once the target is determined, a samples of blood or bone marrow is obtained, nucleic acid is extracted, and the sample analyzed for the leukaemic sequence. These tests are very specific, and detect leukaemic cells at levels down to 1 cell in a million, though the limit typically achieved is 1 in 10,000 to 1 in 100,000 cells. For comparison, the limit of what one can detect using traditional morphologic examinations using a microscope is about 1 cell in 100.
Immunological tests
Immunological based testing of leukaemias utilizes proteins on the surface of the cells. White blood cells (WBC) can show a variety of proteins on the surface depending upon the type of WBC. Leukaemic cells often show quite unusual and unique combinations (leukemic phenotype) of these cell surface proteins. These proteins can be stained with fluorescent dye labeled antibodies and detected using flow cytometryFlow cytometry
Flow cytometry is a technique for counting and examining microscopic particles, such as cells and chromosomes, by suspending them in a stream of fluid and passing them by an electronic detection apparatus. It allows simultaneous multiparametric analysis of the physical and/or chemical...
. The limit of detection of immunological tests is generally about 1 in 10,000 cells and cannot be used on leukaemias that don’t have an identifiable and stable leukaemic phenotype.
Use of and common targets in minimal residual disease detection in different leukaemias, lymphomas and solid tumors
Acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL)
Targets:t(9;22) BCR-ABL, t(12;21) ETV6-RUNX1 (TEL-AML1), Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes
Uses: Chromosomal translocation MRD detection is widely used as a standard clinical practice. Patient specific assays are gaining acceptance but are still generally only used in research protocols.
Acute myeloid leukaemia (AML)
Targets:t(15;17) PML-RARA, t(8;21) AML1-RUNX1
RUNX1
Runt-related transcription factor 1 also known as acute myeloid leukemia 1 protein or core-binding factor subunit alpha-2 is a protein that in humans is encoded by the RUNX1 gene....
T1 (AML-ETO), inv(16)
Uses: Chromosomal translocation MRD detection widely used as a standard clinical practice.
Chronic lymphocytic leukaemia
Targets:Cell surface proteins, Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes
Uses: Immunological methods are gaining wider use as more advanced flow cytometers are utilized for clinical testing. Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Chronic myelogenous leukemiaChronic myelogenous leukemiaChronic myelogenous leukemia , also known as chronic granulocytic leukemia , is a cancer of the white blood cells. It is a form of leukemia characterized by the increased and unregulated growth of predominantly myeloid cells in the bone marrow and the accumulation of these cells in the blood...
Target:t(9;22) BCR-ABL
Uses: MRD detection of the t(9;22) is considered standard of care for all patients with CML and is extremely valuable for patients being treated with imatinib mesylate (Gleevec/Glivec).
Follicular lymphomaFollicular lymphomaFollicular lymphoma is the most common of the indolent non-Hodgkin's lymphomas, and the second most common form of non-Hodgkin's lymphomas overall. It is defined as a lymphoma of follicle center B-cells , which has at least a partially follicular pattern...
Targets:t(14;18) IgH/BCL2, Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes.
Uses: The t(14;18) is regularly used for MRD detection. Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Mantle cell lymphomaMantle cell lymphomaMantle cell lymphoma is one of the rarest of the non-Hodgkin's lymphomas , comprising about 6% of NHL cases. There are only about 15,000 patients presently in the U.S. While it is difficult to treat and seldom considered cured, investigations into better treatments are actively pursued worldwide...
Targets:t(11;14) IgH/CCND1 (IgH/BCL1), Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes
Uses: The t(11;14) is regularly used for MRD detection, but the assay can only reliably detect 40-60% of the t(11;14) translocations. Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Multiple myelomaMultiple myelomaMultiple myeloma , also known as plasma cell myeloma or Kahler's disease , is a cancer of plasma cells, a type of white blood cell normally responsible for the production of antibodies...
Targets:M-protein levels in blood, Patient specific assays for immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes (high levels of somatic hypermutation
Somatic hypermutation
Somatic hypermutation is a mechanism inside cells that is part of the way the immune system adapts to the new foreign elements that confront it . SHM diversifies the receptors used by the immune system to recognize foreign elements and allows the immune system to adapt its response to new threats...
often prevent this assay from reliably working).
Uses: M-protein level in the blood is standard of care and is used for almost all patients with multiple myeloma.
Patient specific assays are still generally only used in research protocols.
Solid tumors
Research into MRD detection of several solid tumors such as breast cancerBreast cancer
Breast cancer is cancer originating from breast tissue, most commonly from the inner lining of milk ducts or the lobules that supply the ducts with milk. Cancers originating from ducts are known as ductal carcinomas; those originating from lobules are known as lobular carcinomas...
and neuroblastoma
Neuroblastoma
Neuroblastoma is the most common extracranial solid cancer in childhood and the most common cancer in infancy, with an annual incidence of about 650 cases per year in the US , and 100 cases per year in the UK . Close to 50 percent of neuroblastoma cases occur in children younger than two years old...
has been performed. These assays have been used to sample lymph nodes and blood for residual or metastatic tumor cells. Applicable targets for MRD detection have been more difficult to determine in solid tumors and the use of MRD in solid tumors is much less advanced than the use in leukemia and lymphoma.
Animal species other than humans
Leukaemias and lymphomas can be monitored in the same way in non-human animals, but we are not aware of any veterinary applications to date.Level of MRD is a guide to prognosis or relapse risk
In some cases, the level of MRD at a certain time in treatment, is a useful guide, to the patient's prognosis. For instance in childhood leukaemia, doctors traditionally take a bone marrow sample after 5 weeks, and assess the level of leukaemia in that. Even with microscope, they were able to identify a few patients whose disease had not cleared, and those patients received different treatment. MRD tests also make use of this time, but the tests are much more sensitive.When past patients were studied: Patients with high levels at this stage - here "high" means often leukaemia more than 1 cell in 1000, were at risk of relapse. Patients with levels below 1 in 100,000 were very unlikely to relapse. Those in between, some relapsed. This led to the idea that MRD testing could predict outcome, and this has now been shown. The next step is whether, having identified a patient whom standard treatment leaves at high risk - there are different treatments they could be offered, to lower that risk. Several clinical trials are investigating this.
Other research groups have looked at other times in treatment -e.g. 3 months, 6 months, 1 year, or end of current treatment (2 years) and these can predict outcome also.
There are also a few scientific studies, showing that level of MRD after bone marrow transplant, shows the risk of relapsing.
Monitoring people for early signs of recurring leukaemia
Another possible use is to identify if or when someone starts to relapse, early, before symptoms come back. This would mean regular blood or marrow samples. This is being explored mainly in chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML), where one can study the leukaemia in blood, which is easier to sample regularly than bone marrow. The molecular tests can show tumour levels starting to rise, very early, possibly months before symptoms recur. Starting treatment early , might be useful: the patient will be healthier; fewer leukaemic cells to deal with; the cells may be amenable to treatment, since at clinical relapse they have often become more resistant to drugs used.Individualization of treatment
This whole area, comes under individualization of treatment, or if one prefers, identification of risk factors. Currently most patient receive the same treatment: but leukaemia is a very variable disease, and different patients probably have widely different treatment needs, to eradicate the disease.For instance, the initial 5 week induction treatment, might rapidly clear disease for some patients. For others, the same treatment might leave significant amounts of disease . Measuring MRD level, helps doctors decide which patients need what. In other words, it identifies patients individual risk of relapse, and can theoretically allow them to receive just enough treatment to prevent it.
Without MRD information, doctors can do nothing but give the same treatment to all patients. They know that this will be inadequate for some and excessive for others, but there is little else they can do, as it is not possible to tell who needs what. Identification of risk factors, to help individualise treatment, is a big field in medicine.
Treatment for MRD
Generally the approach is to bring a cancer into remission first (absence of symptoms) and then try to eradicate the remaining cells (MRD) Often the treatments needed to eradicate MRD, differ from those used initially. This is an area of much research.It seems a sensible idea to aim to reduce or eradicate MRD. What is needed, is evidence on which is the best method, and how well it works. This is emerging. Treatments which specifically target MRD can include.
(a) intensive conventional treatment with more drugs, or a different combination of drugs
(b) stem cell transplant, e.g. marrow transplant. This allows more intensive chemotherapy to be given, and in addition the transplanted bone marrow may help eradicate the minimal residual disease
(c) immunotherapy
(d) monitor the patient carefully for early signs of relapse. This is an area of active research in several countries.
(e) treatment with monoclonal antibodies which target cancer cells
(f) cancer vaccines
Clinical usefulness of MRD tests
It's important that doctors interpreting tests, base what they say, on scientific evidence. If you visit hospital and get tested for something - e.g. a blood count - most of the tests are used often, and have been done thousands or millions of times before, on many different people. The doctors reading the test results, have a large body of evidence, to interpret what the results mean. By contrast, MRD tests are new, and the diseases are uncommon. The tests have been done on relatively few people. Consequently there is less evidence available, to guide doctors, in interpreting the tests, or basing treatment decisions on them. In plain English, this means the doctors are likely to be very cautious, and rely more on other tests which they know and trust, than these. At least at present, while evidence is accumulating. -Method for testing, and when to test
There are controversies about the best times to test, and the best test method to use. There are national and international approaches to standardize these. In childhood leukaemia and chronic myeloid leukaemia, there appears to be consensus emerging.Is there such a thing as a safe level of MRD
There is also controversy about whether MRD is always bad inevitably causing relapse - or whether sometimes low levels are 'safe' and do not regrow. It is usually assumed, cancer cells inevitably grow and that if they are present disease usually develops. But there is some evidence from animal studies, that leukaemic cells can lie dormant for years in the body and do not regrow. For this reason, i may be that the goal of treating MRD may be to reduce it to a "safe" level - not to eradicate it completely.Is MRD testing useful for all patients?
Some types of leukaemia are difficult to treat. In these, it is not clear how MRD testing would help. The patients may not do well on current treatment, but sometimes it is not clear what other treatment, if anything, might be better. There is thus an argument that as the test is not necessary: it might involve an additional procedure for the patient; it will contribute no useful information on treatment, it is not necessary.Where done
MRD testing is not yet a routine test, nor is it carried out in all places.Currently most MRD testing - in leukaemia research - is done during clinical trials, and would be funded as part of that trial, for patients enrolled on the trial. The tests are specialised, so samples are usually sent to a central reference laboratory in each region or country. The tests are not done in most routine diagnostic labs, as they tend to be complex, and also would be used relatively infrequently.
Cost
MRD testing is technically demanding and time consuming; the tests are expensive, so are usually available only through specialist centres, as part of clinical trials.Availability of MRD testing.
At the time of writing (Jan 2008) MRD testing is available in some clinical trials in the UK, Europe, Australia and the US.Interpretation of MRD test results.
Most clinical tests used to guide treatment - e.g. even a simple blood count - have been done millions of times, and doctors can interpret the results confidently, based on this extensive previous knowledge. By contrast, MRD tests are new and have been carried out on relatively few people (a few thousand at most). Researchers and doctors are still building the extensive database of knowledge needed, to show what MRD tests mean.The consequence: unless a patient is enrolled on a trial which requires the test - clinicians tend to be somewhat cautious about requesting it, and cautious about interpreting the results. This is likely to change in future, as tests become more routine.
General
- Leukaemia Research Fund (United Kingdom)
- Children with Leukaemia (United Kingdom)