Helen Smith (nurse)
Encyclopedia
Helen Smith was a British nurse who died in suspicious circumstances in Jeddah
, Saudi Arabia
.
Following a party at the house of Dr. Richard Arnot and his wife Penny, the bodies of Helen (23) and Johannes Otten (35), a Dutch tugboat
captain, were found in the street 70 feet below the Arnots' sixth floor balcony. Helen was found lying in the road fully clothed and Johannes, whose underpants were around his thighs, was impaled upon the spiked railings surrounding the apartment block.
Also present at the Arnots' that night were Tim Hayter, a diver from New Zealand
, a marine biologist named Jaques Texier, four German salvage operators and quite a number of other people who were never traced.
The presence of alcohol at the party in a "dry" country, and evidence given by Jaques Texier of a sexual encounter between Tim Hayter and Mrs Arnot at the time of the deaths, led to increased interest in the case, and the prosecution of Mrs Arnot by the Saudi authorities for 'Unlawful intercourse'.
The official Saudi investigation into the accident concluded that the couple had fallen from the balcony while drunk, possibly after or during a sexual encounter. This conclusion was endorsed by the British Foreign Office.
Mrs Arnot was sentenced to eighty strokes of the cane, to be administered in public, although the sentence was never carried out.
Helen's father Ron Smith, a retired police officer, refused to accept the conclusion and embarked upon a lengthy campaign to expose what he considered to be a Saudi/British coverup. At her father's insistence, Helen's body was left unburied for over 30 years in storage at Leeds General Infirmary
, thought to be the longest time a body has been stored without burial in the United Kingdom. Some six different post mortem examinations and forensic investigations were performed over this period, with varying conclusions.
The death of Helen Smith and her father's subsequent campaign led to a change in the rules regarding inquests into violent or unnatural deaths abroad. The West Yorkshire Coroner, Philip Gill had declined to hold an inquest, concluding that the case was outside his jurisdiction. However, although his decision was upheld by the High Court, in July 1982 the Court of Appeal ordered the inquest to go ahead. The ruling imposed a duty on coroners to investigate deaths abroad where the body was returned to the United Kingdom. The hearing was billed as the inquest of the century, but failed to give Ron Smith the closure he had wanted. The jury returned an open verdict. The 1982 ruling had an impact on thousands of cases and was later cited as a reason for the decision to hold an inquest into the death of Diana, Princess of Wales
.
Although her father had insisted that Helen would not receive a funeral until the full circumstances of her death had been uncovered, following discussions with Helen's mother he agreed to hold a funeral while both of them were still alive. Smith's remains were cremated on 9 November 2009 over 30 years after her death. Her ashes were scattered on Ilkley Moor. Ron Smith died on 15 April 2011.
Jeddah
Jeddah, Jiddah, Jidda, or Jedda is a city located on the coast of the Red Sea and is the major urban center of western Saudi Arabia. It is the largest city in Makkah Province, the largest sea port on the Red Sea, and the second largest city in Saudi Arabia after the capital city, Riyadh. The...
, Saudi Arabia
Saudi Arabia
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia , commonly known in British English as Saudi Arabia and in Arabic as as-Sa‘ūdiyyah , is the largest state in Western Asia by land area, constituting the bulk of the Arabian Peninsula, and the second-largest in the Arab World...
.
Following a party at the house of Dr. Richard Arnot and his wife Penny, the bodies of Helen (23) and Johannes Otten (35), a Dutch tugboat
Tugboat
A tugboat is a boat that maneuvers vessels by pushing or towing them. Tugs move vessels that either should not move themselves, such as ships in a crowded harbor or a narrow canal,or those that cannot move by themselves, such as barges, disabled ships, or oil platforms. Tugboats are powerful for...
captain, were found in the street 70 feet below the Arnots' sixth floor balcony. Helen was found lying in the road fully clothed and Johannes, whose underpants were around his thighs, was impaled upon the spiked railings surrounding the apartment block.
Also present at the Arnots' that night were Tim Hayter, a diver from New Zealand
New Zealand
New Zealand is an island country in the south-western Pacific Ocean comprising two main landmasses and numerous smaller islands. The country is situated some east of Australia across the Tasman Sea, and roughly south of the Pacific island nations of New Caledonia, Fiji, and Tonga...
, a marine biologist named Jaques Texier, four German salvage operators and quite a number of other people who were never traced.
The presence of alcohol at the party in a "dry" country, and evidence given by Jaques Texier of a sexual encounter between Tim Hayter and Mrs Arnot at the time of the deaths, led to increased interest in the case, and the prosecution of Mrs Arnot by the Saudi authorities for 'Unlawful intercourse'.
The official Saudi investigation into the accident concluded that the couple had fallen from the balcony while drunk, possibly after or during a sexual encounter. This conclusion was endorsed by the British Foreign Office.
Mrs Arnot was sentenced to eighty strokes of the cane, to be administered in public, although the sentence was never carried out.
Helen's father Ron Smith, a retired police officer, refused to accept the conclusion and embarked upon a lengthy campaign to expose what he considered to be a Saudi/British coverup. At her father's insistence, Helen's body was left unburied for over 30 years in storage at Leeds General Infirmary
Leeds General Infirmary
Leeds General Infirmary, also known as the LGI or, more correctly, The General Infirmary at Leeds, is a large teaching hospital based in the centre of Leeds, West Yorkshire, England and is part of the Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust....
, thought to be the longest time a body has been stored without burial in the United Kingdom. Some six different post mortem examinations and forensic investigations were performed over this period, with varying conclusions.
The death of Helen Smith and her father's subsequent campaign led to a change in the rules regarding inquests into violent or unnatural deaths abroad. The West Yorkshire Coroner, Philip Gill had declined to hold an inquest, concluding that the case was outside his jurisdiction. However, although his decision was upheld by the High Court, in July 1982 the Court of Appeal ordered the inquest to go ahead. The ruling imposed a duty on coroners to investigate deaths abroad where the body was returned to the United Kingdom. The hearing was billed as the inquest of the century, but failed to give Ron Smith the closure he had wanted. The jury returned an open verdict. The 1982 ruling had an impact on thousands of cases and was later cited as a reason for the decision to hold an inquest into the death of Diana, Princess of Wales
Diana, Princess of Wales
Diana, Princess of Wales was the first wife of Charles, Prince of Wales, whom she married on 29 July 1981, and an international charity and fundraising figure, as well as a preeminent celebrity of the late 20th century...
.
Although her father had insisted that Helen would not receive a funeral until the full circumstances of her death had been uncovered, following discussions with Helen's mother he agreed to hold a funeral while both of them were still alive. Smith's remains were cremated on 9 November 2009 over 30 years after her death. Her ashes were scattered on Ilkley Moor. Ron Smith died on 15 April 2011.
Further reading
- Paul FootPaul FootPaul Mackintosh Foot was a British investigative journalist, political campaigner, author, and long-time member of the Socialist Workers Party...
- The Helen Smith Story (Fontana) ISBN 978-0006365365 - Gordon Wilson and Dave Harrison - "Inquest" (Methuen) ISBN 0413531708
- Richard Arnot - Arabian Nightmare (Unwin) ISBN 1-89448-647-3
- Geoffrey Robertson - The Justice Game (Vintage) ISBN 0099581914