William F. Cellini
Encyclopedia
William F. Cellini is co-founder of the New Frontier Companies, a group of Illinois-based real estate companies with headquarters in Chicago that employ more than 250 people statewide. He was previously the chairman of the NYSE-listed Argosy Gaming Company
, was the treasurer of the Sangamon County Republican Party and has held several public offices within the state of Illinois.
He is also Executive Director of the Illinois Asphalt Pavement Association, a position he parlayed into a 50-year career as a top lobbyist and fund-raiser for Illinois politicians . On November 1, 2011 Cellini was convicted in federal court on charges of extortion and bribery in connection with a scheme to shake down movie producer Tom Rosenberg for a campaign contribution to then-Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich. He is currently awaiting sentencing, and could face a prison term of up to 30 years.
Mr. Cellini has served on the boards of Lakeside Bank of Chicago, the Illinois National Bank of Springfield, Roosevelt National Life Insurance Company, Illinois College Board of Trustees, and the Boys & Girls Club of Springfield, Illinois. He was the statewide chairman of the USO, and has appeared on numerous professional panels for the road building industry. In 2007 he received the Bradley University
Department of Engineering Outstanding Achievement Award. He is a member of the Lanphier High School
Hall of Fame.
A classically trained musician, he plays piano and had a dance band that played throughout the Midwest from 1953 to 1969. He was elected chairman of the American Federation of Musicians Local 19 and he remains a lifetime member of the American Federation of Musicians
.
working the 11pm to 7am shift for 20 of those years. During Cellini's childhood, his mother Edith took-in laundry and worked as a waitress at their family's restaurant. Later in life, she was a cashier in the office of the Sangamon County Treasurer.
Cellini was president of his graduating grade school class and attended Lanphier High School, graduating in 1952. He was the first member of his immediate family to attend college, and graduated with a degree in physics from Illinois College
in the late 1950s. In 1960, he was on faculty at Niantic-Harristown High School in Niantic, Illinois
where he taught physics, algebra and English. To help pay his way through college, Cellini toured and played dances in Central Illinois with his own bands, The Hi-Fis and the Bill Cellini Orchestra. His first professional job was in 1953 at The Skyrocket Inn, a nightclub on the North End of Springfield.
, a former reporter and now free-lance writer. They reside in Springfield and are the parents of William Jr., a documentary film maker, and Claudia, who owns and operates The Third Line in Dubai
, United Arab Emirates
. Both William Jr. and Claudia work as directors in their family's business. William and Julianna also have one grandchild who lives with her parents and her three saluki
rescues
in Dubai.
In 1969, Governor Richard B. Ogilvie
appointed William Cellini to be the Director of Public Works and Buildings for Illinois. In 1971, he was appointed Illinois' first Secretary of Transportation and directed several thousand employees while administering an annual budget of over a billion dollar dollars in public works programs.
In April 1972, the Illinois State Senate unanimously confirmed Cellini as the first secretary of the newly created Illinois Department of Transportation
, putting him in charge of 10,000 employees and a budget of more than $1.5 billion. The election of Democrat Dan Walker
as Governor the following year ended Cellini's career in state government.
Beginning in 1974, Cellini embarked on a long and successful career in the private sector. With his business partner Larry Haddad, he co-founded the New Frontier Companies, a full service real estate development firm, and in addition, Cellini became executive director of the Illinois Asphalt Pavement Association.
Cellini remained politically active in the private sector serving as Treasurer of the Sangamon County Republican Central Committee in Springfield. In the mid-1970s, he was appointed by the President of the United States to serve on the National Highway Safety Advisory Committee and in 1976 at the age of 41, Cellini was a delegate to the Republican National Convention in Kansas City, Missouri where from the floor of the convention hall he seconded the nomination of Gerald R. Ford for President by giving a brief speech he wrote on the back of a campaign sign.
In 1977, Cellini and Haddad formed New Frontier Management Corporation, a company that has overseen the management, rent-up and asset management of over 17,000 housing units throughout the United States. In 1989 he founded Pacific Management Inc., from which he is now retired. In addition to these business ventures, Cellini took an active role in commercial product design by inventing and patenting two types of Shower Enlarger curtain rods which maximize bathtub showering space and are currently used in many hotels across the United States.
From 1973 to the present Cellini, as Executive Director, along with Dr. Marvin Traylor, has managed the Illinois Asphalt Pavement Association, the Illinois Association of Wastewater Agencies, the Illinois Concrete Pipe Association and PCI of Illinois and Wisconsin.
. After an extensive vetting and qualifying process, Cellini became the co-founder of Argosy Gaming Company
in 1999, a New York Stock Exchange traded entity. The company's first gambling license cost the company $85,000 but later blossomed into a value of $500 million with six casinos.
of Illinois (TRS). In 2009, CRA was one of that system’s biggest moneymakers; earning the pension fund about 20 percent over the previous five years. The executive director of TRS even commended CRA's performance citing it as the pension fund's top-performing real-estate manager. CRA earned double-digit returns for the Illinois teacher's pension for 17 consecutive years. CRA grew to manage in excess of $900 million in equity and approximately $2 billion in gross assets before its closure in 2009.
to shake down an investment firm for campaign contributions to a public official believed to be Governor Rod Blagojevich
. The indictment alleges that Cellini aided Rezko, Levine and another, unnamed co-conspirator in a plot to raise the campaign contributions. The objective was to get the money from Capri Capital and one of its owners, Hollywood producer Thomas Rosenberg”
Rezko was acquitted of charges related to Rosenburg and Capri Capital.
According to the indictment Cellini would use his power to block Capri from getting a contract to manage $220 million in the Teachers Retirement System unless it made substantial payments to the Governor. After Rosenberg threatened to report the threats, they allegedly backed off and Capri got the contract.
After Cellini's indictment was made public, his attorney Dan K. Webb released a statement saying Cellini "is completely innocent of these charges, and he will fight this case because he has done absolutely nothing wrong. Bill has lived an exemplary life as a successful businessman and devoted husband and father, and he will not allow his reputation to be damaged by these unfair and unjust charges. Bill is confident that a jury will find him not guilty.".
finalized the selection of twelve jurors and four alternates. The defense made a motion under Batson v. Kentucky
, asserting that the government unfairly eliminated minorities from the jury. The defense reasoned that of the six permitted removals, the government eliminated four minorities; of the two permitted alternate removals, both were minorities. The government countered the defense was attempting to unfairly remove white men from the jury pool, arguing of the ten permitted removals seven were white men. Judge Zagel denied both motions but ordered each side to present its reasons for juror removal in a sealed envelope for purposes of appellate review. Speculation in the courtroom surmised that the government believed minorities would not view the government’s case favorably because of the immunity and plea bargains offered to most prosecution witnesses. Particularly Stuart Levine, who was described by both sides as having committed numerous crimes including drug use and dealing—yet has not served a single day in prison.
While prosecution provided evidence against Cellini during Levine's testimony, Levine's credibility was called into question. Under questioning by Assistant U.S. Attorney Christopher Niewoehner, Levine gave mostly monotone answers about malfeasance while he served on the board at the Illinois Teachers' Retirement System- TRS. At one point on the stand, Levine became flustered when his cell phone rang and he struggled to silence it. Levine finally handed it over to Niewoehner..
But when Levine was cross examined, his conduct changed. In contrast to his rapid, mechanical answers offered to the prosecution, Levine stalled continuously when asked to recall his own testimony offered on the stand just hours before.,ref
He often appeared disoriented, pausing for 10 seconds or more as the courtroom grew quiet. Webb hit Levine with a barrage of questions about how much money he stole, how many institutions he cheated and how he felt about it all. Levine paused long and often in his answers yet had no answer when Webb asked how many dishonest acts he had committed..
On October 19, Tom Rosenberg took the stand as a government witness. After cooperating for months with the FBI, Rosenberg was granted immunity in exchange for his testimony. Prosecutors portrayed Rosenberg as an un-willing participant in the political contribution scheme. This stood in direct contrast to Levine's sworn testimony about Rosenberg’s influence. At times, Rosenberg aided Cellini's case by testifying Cellini never asked him to make a political contribution nor asked for any money. “Never in 30 years,” Rosenberg said of his longtime business friend. Rosenberg also claimed Levine never wanted money from him.
Closing arguments were presented to the jury on October 25. Prosecutors contended Cellini was at the center of a plot to extort Thomas Rosenberg. Defense attorney Dan Webb said Cellini was used by Levine and was made a scapegoat by the government. The prosecution emphasized the calls between Levine and Cellini recorded by the FBI and claimed, because Cellini was talking on the phone during the time of the alleged extortion plot, it made him a willing member of the plot. Webb contended while Cellini talked to Levine, he never told him he gave Rosenberg an extortion message. “I want you to read every page of this transcript,” Webb told jurors. “Cellini does not pass on the extortion message. It’s not there.”
The alleged extortion involved a crucial telephone call mentioned on the stand by Levine when he claimed Cellini helped plot a scheme with him. Evidence in court proved the government never recorded that key call. Webb drove home this fact to the jury, that out of all calls the government recorded it did not record the one where Levine allegedly told [Cellini] to deliver the extortion threat to Rosenberg. “We have no tape recording,” Webb said. “We have nothing but Levine’s testimony.”
Webb explained Cellini wasn’t in meetings when a supposed conspiracy was planned. "‘[he] didn’t know what took place during them and would never have received any money as a result of the conspiracy. In fact, Cellini didn’t even know Levine, Kelly and Rezko were conspiring to extort Rosenberg’, Webb said." Prosecutors rebutted saying it was irrelevant whether Cellini told Rosenberg he had to pay.
A crucial moment of the alleged extortion involved a call mentioned on the stand by Levine. He claimed Cellini helped plot a scheme with him. But evidence in court showed that the government never recorded that call. Webb drove home this fact to the jury, that out of all the calls the government recorded between Levine and Cellini, it did not record one on May 2 in which Levine allegedly told [Cellini] to deliver the extortion threat to Rosenberg. “We have no tape recording,” Webb said. “We have nothing but Levine’s testimony.”
On November 1, 2011, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty on all but two counts. In speaking with the press, Cellini’s attorney provided the following statement:
We are very gratified that the jury found Mr. Cellini not guilty of the most serious charges in the indictment. Mr. Cellini was found not guilty of the major conspiracy count, Count 1, in which the Government alleged a conspiracy to commit honest services crimes for 15 months. Further, the jury found Mr. Cellini not guilty of even attempting to extort money from Mr. Rosenberg, Count 3. Whatever the jury determined Mr. Cellini did to be guilty of a conspiracy to commit extortion, Count 2, that conduct did not even rise to the level of being an attempted extortion.
As far as the counts on which Mr. Cellini was found guilty, we are confident we will be able to obtain a reversal on appeal.
Argosy Gaming Company
Argosy Gaming Company was an Alton, Illinois based casino operator.-History:The company through the political connections of its chairman William F. Cellini received the first gambling license in Illinois in modern times. It began operations in September, 1991 with the opening of the Alton Belle...
, was the treasurer of the Sangamon County Republican Party and has held several public offices within the state of Illinois.
He is also Executive Director of the Illinois Asphalt Pavement Association, a position he parlayed into a 50-year career as a top lobbyist and fund-raiser for Illinois politicians . On November 1, 2011 Cellini was convicted in federal court on charges of extortion and bribery in connection with a scheme to shake down movie producer Tom Rosenberg for a campaign contribution to then-Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich. He is currently awaiting sentencing, and could face a prison term of up to 30 years.
Mr. Cellini has served on the boards of Lakeside Bank of Chicago, the Illinois National Bank of Springfield, Roosevelt National Life Insurance Company, Illinois College Board of Trustees, and the Boys & Girls Club of Springfield, Illinois. He was the statewide chairman of the USO, and has appeared on numerous professional panels for the road building industry. In 2007 he received the Bradley University
Bradley University
Bradley University, founded in 1897, is a private, co-educational university located in Peoria, Illinois. It is a small institution with an enrollment of approximately 6,100 undergraduate and postgraduate students and a full-time faculty of approximately 350....
Department of Engineering Outstanding Achievement Award. He is a member of the Lanphier High School
Lanphier High School
Lanphier High School, in the capital of the U.S. state of Illinois, Springfield, is a public high school affiliated with Springfield Public School District 186...
Hall of Fame.
A classically trained musician, he plays piano and had a dance band that played throughout the Midwest from 1953 to 1969. He was elected chairman of the American Federation of Musicians Local 19 and he remains a lifetime member of the American Federation of Musicians
American Federation of Musicians
The American Federation of Musicians of the United States and Canada is a labor union of professional musicians in the United States and Canada...
.
Early Life
William Cellini was born in Springfield, Illinois in 1934. His family lived and worked in the blue-collar North End of Springfield. From the 1930s until the 1960s, the neighborhood where he lived was an enclave of Southern and Eastern European families. Most of the fathers on his block were coal miners or worked in Springfield's factories. His father, William Cellini Sr., was a coal miner and amateur boxer from the age of 12 until he was 22 when he became a 37-year member of the Springfield Police DepartmentSpringfield Police Department (Illinois)
The Springfield Police Department is the law enforcement agency responsible for the city of Springfield, Illinois.-Fallen officers:Since the establishment of the Springfield Police Department, 10 officers have died in the line of duty.-See also:...
working the 11pm to 7am shift for 20 of those years. During Cellini's childhood, his mother Edith took-in laundry and worked as a waitress at their family's restaurant. Later in life, she was a cashier in the office of the Sangamon County Treasurer.
Cellini was president of his graduating grade school class and attended Lanphier High School, graduating in 1952. He was the first member of his immediate family to attend college, and graduated with a degree in physics from Illinois College
Illinois College
Illinois College is a private, liberal arts college, affiliated with the United Church of Christ and the Presbyterian Church , and located in Jacksonville, Illinois. It was the second college founded in Illinois, but the first to grant a degree . It was founded in 1829 by the Illinois Band,...
in the late 1950s. In 1960, he was on faculty at Niantic-Harristown High School in Niantic, Illinois
Niantic, Illinois
Niantic is a village in Macon County, Illinois, United States whose population was 738 at the 2000 census.It is included in the Decatur, Illinois Metropolitan Statistical Area.-Geography:Niantic is located at ....
where he taught physics, algebra and English. To help pay his way through college, Cellini toured and played dances in Central Illinois with his own bands, The Hi-Fis and the Bill Cellini Orchestra. His first professional job was in 1953 at The Skyrocket Inn, a nightclub on the North End of Springfield.
Family
In 1966, he married Julianna (England) CelliniJulie Cellini
Julie Cellini is a free-lance journalist and works on special projects for her family-owned real estate company headquartered in Chicago.She is a trustee for the Illinois Historic Preservation Agency and the Secretary of the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum Foundation...
, a former reporter and now free-lance writer. They reside in Springfield and are the parents of William Jr., a documentary film maker, and Claudia, who owns and operates The Third Line in Dubai
Dubai
Dubai is a city and emirate in the United Arab Emirates . The emirate is located south of the Persian Gulf on the Arabian Peninsula and has the largest population with the second-largest land territory by area of all the emirates, after Abu Dhabi...
, United Arab Emirates
United Arab Emirates
The United Arab Emirates, abbreviated as the UAE, or shortened to "the Emirates", is a state situated in the southeast of the Arabian Peninsula in Western Asia on the Persian Gulf, bordering Oman, and Saudi Arabia, and sharing sea borders with Iraq, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, and Iran.The UAE is a...
. Both William Jr. and Claudia work as directors in their family's business. William and Julianna also have one grandchild who lives with her parents and her three saluki
Saluki
The Saluki, also known as the Royal Dog of Egypt and Persian Greyhound is one of the oldest known breeds of domesticated dog. From the period of the Middle Kingdom onwards, Saluki-like animals appear on the ancient Egyptian tombs of 2134 BC. They have connections both to the Bible and Imperial...
rescues
Rescue dog
A rescue dog is a dog that has been rescued from possible euthanasia after being found as a stray, a dog that has been saved from an abusive or neglectful home by an animal rescue organisation such as the RSPCA in the UK or the ASPCA in the USA, or a dog that is simply no longer wanted or can no...
in Dubai.
Career
After graduating from Illinois College in 1958, Cellini ran for his first public office as police magistrate of Springfield but lost his bid for election. Cellini went on to lose another election for Circuit Clerk of Sangamon County, Illinois but eventually won a seat on the Sangamon County Board of Supervisors in 1961. In 1963, he was elected to serve on the Springfield City Council as Commissioner of Public Works. At 28, he was the youngest man ever elected to the Springfield City Council and the youngest to head its public works department. He was re-elected in 1967 having no opposition.In 1969, Governor Richard B. Ogilvie
Richard B. Ogilvie
Richard Buell Ogilvie was the 35th Governor of Illinois from 1969 to 1973. A wounded combat veteran of World War II, he achieved fame as the mafia-fighting Sheriff of Cook County, Illinois in the 1960s....
appointed William Cellini to be the Director of Public Works and Buildings for Illinois. In 1971, he was appointed Illinois' first Secretary of Transportation and directed several thousand employees while administering an annual budget of over a billion dollar dollars in public works programs.
In April 1972, the Illinois State Senate unanimously confirmed Cellini as the first secretary of the newly created Illinois Department of Transportation
Illinois Department of Transportation
The Illinois Department of Transportation is a state agency in charge of state-maintained public roadways of the U.S. state of Illinois. In addition, IDOT provides funding for rail, public transit and airport projects and administers fuel tax and federal funding to local juridictions in the...
, putting him in charge of 10,000 employees and a budget of more than $1.5 billion. The election of Democrat Dan Walker
Daniel Walker
Daniel Walker was the 36th Governor of the U.S. state of Illinois from 1973 to 1977.-Early life and career:He was born in Washington, D.C. and raised near San Diego, California. He was the second Governor of Illinois to graduate from the United States Naval Academy. He served as a naval officer in...
as Governor the following year ended Cellini's career in state government.
Beginning in 1974, Cellini embarked on a long and successful career in the private sector. With his business partner Larry Haddad, he co-founded the New Frontier Companies, a full service real estate development firm, and in addition, Cellini became executive director of the Illinois Asphalt Pavement Association.
Cellini remained politically active in the private sector serving as Treasurer of the Sangamon County Republican Central Committee in Springfield. In the mid-1970s, he was appointed by the President of the United States to serve on the National Highway Safety Advisory Committee and in 1976 at the age of 41, Cellini was a delegate to the Republican National Convention in Kansas City, Missouri where from the floor of the convention hall he seconded the nomination of Gerald R. Ford for President by giving a brief speech he wrote on the back of a campaign sign.
In 1977, Cellini and Haddad formed New Frontier Management Corporation, a company that has overseen the management, rent-up and asset management of over 17,000 housing units throughout the United States. In 1989 he founded Pacific Management Inc., from which he is now retired. In addition to these business ventures, Cellini took an active role in commercial product design by inventing and patenting two types of Shower Enlarger curtain rods which maximize bathtub showering space and are currently used in many hotels across the United States.
From 1973 to the present Cellini, as Executive Director, along with Dr. Marvin Traylor, has managed the Illinois Asphalt Pavement Association, the Illinois Association of Wastewater Agencies, the Illinois Concrete Pipe Association and PCI of Illinois and Wisconsin.
Argosy Gaming
In 1990, Cellini with a group of ten entrepreneurs, created Metro Entertainment and Tourism to obtain the first casino license in Illinois. The group was successful winning the license and then created the Alton Riverboat Gambling Partnership in East Alton, Illinois. This partnership included tennis star Jimmy ConnorsJimmy Connors
James Scott "Jimmy" Connors is an American former world no. 1 tennis player....
. After an extensive vetting and qualifying process, Cellini became the co-founder of Argosy Gaming Company
Argosy Gaming Company
Argosy Gaming Company was an Alton, Illinois based casino operator.-History:The company through the political connections of its chairman William F. Cellini received the first gambling license in Illinois in modern times. It began operations in September, 1991 with the opening of the Alton Belle...
in 1999, a New York Stock Exchange traded entity. The company's first gambling license cost the company $85,000 but later blossomed into a value of $500 million with six casinos.
Commonwealth Realty Advisors
In 1989, William Cellini and Earl Deutsch founded Commonwealth Realty Advisors (CRA). The firm was a highly successful real-estate investment company focused on retail shopping malls. Its clients included union and public pension funds across the State of Illinois. It's most successful client was the Teachers Retirement SystemIllinois Municipal Retirement Fund
The Illinois Municipal Retirement Fund is a pension fund created in 1939 by the Illinois General Assembly for municipal employees in the state of Illinois. IMRF began operating in 1941 with 5 original employers and $5,000 in assets...
of Illinois (TRS). In 2009, CRA was one of that system’s biggest moneymakers; earning the pension fund about 20 percent over the previous five years. The executive director of TRS even commended CRA's performance citing it as the pension fund's top-performing real-estate manager. CRA earned double-digit returns for the Illinois teacher's pension for 17 consecutive years. CRA grew to manage in excess of $900 million in equity and approximately $2 billion in gross assets before its closure in 2009.
Indictment
On October 30th, 2008 he was indicted on charges of conspiring with convicted fundraiser Tony RezkoTony Rezko
Antoin "Tony" Rezko is a Assyrian -American businessman, political fundraiser, restaurateur, and real estate developer in Chicago, Illinois, convicted on several counts of fraud and bribery in 2008. Rezko has been involved in fundraising for local Illinois Democratic and Republican politicians...
to shake down an investment firm for campaign contributions to a public official believed to be Governor Rod Blagojevich
Rod Blagojevich
Rod R. Blagojevich is an American politician who served as the 40th Governor of Illinois from 2003 to 2009. A Democrat, Blagojevich was a State Representative before being elected to the United States House of Representatives representing parts of Chicago...
. The indictment alleges that Cellini aided Rezko, Levine and another, unnamed co-conspirator in a plot to raise the campaign contributions. The objective was to get the money from Capri Capital and one of its owners, Hollywood producer Thomas Rosenberg”
Rezko was acquitted of charges related to Rosenburg and Capri Capital.
According to the indictment Cellini would use his power to block Capri from getting a contract to manage $220 million in the Teachers Retirement System unless it made substantial payments to the Governor. After Rosenberg threatened to report the threats, they allegedly backed off and Capri got the contract.
After Cellini's indictment was made public, his attorney Dan K. Webb released a statement saying Cellini "is completely innocent of these charges, and he will fight this case because he has done absolutely nothing wrong. Bill has lived an exemplary life as a successful businessman and devoted husband and father, and he will not allow his reputation to be damaged by these unfair and unjust charges. Bill is confident that a jury will find him not guilty.".
Trial
On October 5, 2011, after vetting potential jurors, Judge James ZagelJames Zagel
James Block Zagel is a United States district judge for the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois and a novelist.- Early life and education :...
finalized the selection of twelve jurors and four alternates. The defense made a motion under Batson v. Kentucky
Batson v. Kentucky
Batson v. Kentucky, , was a case in which the United States Supreme Court ruled that a prosecutor's use of peremptory challenge—the dismissal of jurors without stating a valid cause for doing so—may not be used to exclude jurors based solely on their race...
, asserting that the government unfairly eliminated minorities from the jury. The defense reasoned that of the six permitted removals, the government eliminated four minorities; of the two permitted alternate removals, both were minorities. The government countered the defense was attempting to unfairly remove white men from the jury pool, arguing of the ten permitted removals seven were white men. Judge Zagel denied both motions but ordered each side to present its reasons for juror removal in a sealed envelope for purposes of appellate review. Speculation in the courtroom surmised that the government believed minorities would not view the government’s case favorably because of the immunity and plea bargains offered to most prosecution witnesses. Particularly Stuart Levine, who was described by both sides as having committed numerous crimes including drug use and dealing—yet has not served a single day in prison.
While prosecution provided evidence against Cellini during Levine's testimony, Levine's credibility was called into question. Under questioning by Assistant U.S. Attorney Christopher Niewoehner, Levine gave mostly monotone answers about malfeasance while he served on the board at the Illinois Teachers' Retirement System- TRS. At one point on the stand, Levine became flustered when his cell phone rang and he struggled to silence it. Levine finally handed it over to Niewoehner..
But when Levine was cross examined, his conduct changed. In contrast to his rapid, mechanical answers offered to the prosecution, Levine stalled continuously when asked to recall his own testimony offered on the stand just hours before.,ref
He often appeared disoriented, pausing for 10 seconds or more as the courtroom grew quiet. Webb hit Levine with a barrage of questions about how much money he stole, how many institutions he cheated and how he felt about it all. Levine paused long and often in his answers yet had no answer when Webb asked how many dishonest acts he had committed..
On October 19, Tom Rosenberg took the stand as a government witness. After cooperating for months with the FBI, Rosenberg was granted immunity in exchange for his testimony. Prosecutors portrayed Rosenberg as an un-willing participant in the political contribution scheme. This stood in direct contrast to Levine's sworn testimony about Rosenberg’s influence. At times, Rosenberg aided Cellini's case by testifying Cellini never asked him to make a political contribution nor asked for any money. “Never in 30 years,” Rosenberg said of his longtime business friend. Rosenberg also claimed Levine never wanted money from him.
Closing arguments were presented to the jury on October 25. Prosecutors contended Cellini was at the center of a plot to extort Thomas Rosenberg. Defense attorney Dan Webb said Cellini was used by Levine and was made a scapegoat by the government. The prosecution emphasized the calls between Levine and Cellini recorded by the FBI and claimed, because Cellini was talking on the phone during the time of the alleged extortion plot, it made him a willing member of the plot. Webb contended while Cellini talked to Levine, he never told him he gave Rosenberg an extortion message. “I want you to read every page of this transcript,” Webb told jurors. “Cellini does not pass on the extortion message. It’s not there.”
The alleged extortion involved a crucial telephone call mentioned on the stand by Levine when he claimed Cellini helped plot a scheme with him. Evidence in court proved the government never recorded that key call. Webb drove home this fact to the jury, that out of all calls the government recorded it did not record the one where Levine allegedly told [Cellini] to deliver the extortion threat to Rosenberg. “We have no tape recording,” Webb said. “We have nothing but Levine’s testimony.”
Webb explained Cellini wasn’t in meetings when a supposed conspiracy was planned. "‘[he] didn’t know what took place during them and would never have received any money as a result of the conspiracy. In fact, Cellini didn’t even know Levine, Kelly and Rezko were conspiring to extort Rosenberg’, Webb said." Prosecutors rebutted saying it was irrelevant whether Cellini told Rosenberg he had to pay.
A crucial moment of the alleged extortion involved a call mentioned on the stand by Levine. He claimed Cellini helped plot a scheme with him. But evidence in court showed that the government never recorded that call. Webb drove home this fact to the jury, that out of all the calls the government recorded between Levine and Cellini, it did not record one on May 2 in which Levine allegedly told [Cellini] to deliver the extortion threat to Rosenberg. “We have no tape recording,” Webb said. “We have nothing but Levine’s testimony.”
On November 1, 2011, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty on all but two counts. In speaking with the press, Cellini’s attorney provided the following statement:
We are very gratified that the jury found Mr. Cellini not guilty of the most serious charges in the indictment. Mr. Cellini was found not guilty of the major conspiracy count, Count 1, in which the Government alleged a conspiracy to commit honest services crimes for 15 months. Further, the jury found Mr. Cellini not guilty of even attempting to extort money from Mr. Rosenberg, Count 3. Whatever the jury determined Mr. Cellini did to be guilty of a conspiracy to commit extortion, Count 2, that conduct did not even rise to the level of being an attempted extortion.
As far as the counts on which Mr. Cellini was found guilty, we are confident we will be able to obtain a reversal on appeal.