Key

• WC = Walter Camp
• MS = Frank Menke Syndicate, by Frank G. Menke
  Frank G. Menke
  Frank Grant Menke was an American newspaper reporter, author, and sports historian. He wrote for the Hearst Newspapers from 1912 to 1932 and his articles appeared daily in 300 newspapers across the country. He was billed by the Hearst syndicate as "America's Foremost Sport Writer"...
  
  
• TM = Robert "Tiny" Maxwell
  Tiny Maxwell
  Robert W. "Tiny" Maxwell was a professional football player and referee. He was also a sports editor with the Philadelphia Public Ledger.-Early life:...
  
  , of the Philadelphia Public Ledger
• Bold - Consensus All-American
• 1 - First Team Selection
• 2 - Second Team Selection
• 3 - Third Team Selection

Ends

• Paul Robeson
  Paul Robeson
  Paul Leroy Robeson was an American concert singer , recording artist, actor, athlete, scholar who was an advocate for the Civil Rights Movement in the first half of the twentieth century...
  
  , Rutgers (WC-1; MS; TM-1)
• Bill Fincher
  Bill Fincher
  -External links:...
  
  , Georgia Tech (MS; TM-1)
• Robert Hopper, Penn (WC-1; MS; TM-2)
• Harrington, Pittsburgh (TM-2)
• Weeks, Brown (WC-2)
• Fincher, Georgia Tech (WC-2)
• Schwarzes, Syracuse (WC-3)
• Tressel, John Washington & Jefferson
  Washington & Jefferson Presidents football
  The Washington & Jefferson Presidents football team represents Washington & Jefferson College in collegiate level football. The team competes in NCAA Division III and is affiliated with the Presidents' Athletic Conference...
  
   (WC-3)

Tackles

• Wilbur Henry, Washington & Jefferson
  Washington & Jefferson Presidents football
  The Washington & Jefferson Presidents football team represents Washington & Jefferson College in collegiate level football. The team competes in NCAA Division III and is affiliated with the Presidents' Athletic Conference...
  
   (College and Pro Football Hall of Fame) (WC-2; MS; TM-1)
• Leonard Hilty, Pittsburgh (WC-1; TM-2)
• Lou Usher
  Lou Usher
  Louis "Lou" Childs Usher was a professional American football player who played offensive lineman for five seasons for the Rochester Jeffersons, Chicago Bears, Hammond Pros, Kenosha Maroons, and Milwaukee Badgers....
  
  , Syracuse (WC-1; TM-2)
• Joe Guyon
  Joe Guyon
  Joseph Napoleon Guyon was a professional American football player in the National Football League...
  
  , Georgia Tech (MS)
• Robert Hopper, Penn (WC-1)
• Larkin, Swarthmore (TM-1)
• Ripley, North Carolina (WC-2)
• Angus Goetz
  Angus Goetz
  Angus Gerald "Gus" Goetz was an American football player who played four years with the Michigan Wolverines from 1917 to 1920. He also played professional football for the Buffalo All-Americans and the Columbus Tigers .-University of Michigan:A native of Sault Ste...
  
  , Michigan (WC-3)
• Neylon, Penn (WC-3)

Guards

• Joe Alexander, Syracuse (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; MS; TM-1)
• Lyman Perry, Navy (WC-1; MS; TM-1)
• Jake Stahl
  Jake Stahl
  Jacob Garland "Jake" Stahl was an American first baseman and manager in Major League Baseball with the Boston Red Sox, Washington Senators, and New York Highlanders. A graduate of the University of Illinois, he was a member of the Kappa Kappa chapter of Sigma Chi...
  
  , Pittsburgh (WC-2; TM-2)
• Neuschaefer, Rutgers (TM-2)
• Scaffe, Navy (WC-2)
• Huggins, Brown (WC-3)
• Walter A. Gordon
  Walter A. Gordon
  Walter Arthur Gordon was the first African American to receive a doctorate of law from UC Berkeley's Boalt Hall law school. He had an extremely long and varied career where he served as a police officer, lawyer, assistant football coach, member of the California Adult Authority, Governor of the...
  
  , California (WC-3)

Centers

• Ashel Day, Georgia Tech (WC-1)
• John Depler, Illinois (WC-2; MS)
• Sterck, Washington & Jefferson
  Washington & Jefferson Presidents football
  The Washington & Jefferson Presidents football team represents Washington & Jefferson College in collegiate level football. The team competes in NCAA Division III and is affiliated with the Presidents' Athletic Conference...
  
   (TM-1)
• Arthur, Navy (TM-2)
• Calahan, Princeton (WC-3)

Quartebacks

• Frank Murrey
  Frank Murrey
  Frank Murrey was an American football player and track athlete. He played quarterback for Princeton University from 1918–1921 and was selected as an All-American quarterback by Walter Camp in 1918. In 1920, Murrey ran 77 yards for a touchdown in Princeton's 14-0 victory over Navy...
  
  , Princeton (WC-1; MS)
• Ackley, Syracuse (WC-3; TM-1)
• Ingram, Navy (TM-2)
• Robb, California (WC-2)

Halfbacks

• Tom Davies
  Tom Davies
  Thomas J. Davies was an American football player and coach. He played as a halfback at the University of Pittsburgh and was a consensus All-American in 1918 and 1920...
  
  , Pittsburgh (WC-1; MS; TM-1)
• Wolcott Roberts, Navy (WC-1; MS)
• Katy Easterday
  Katy Easterday
  Roy Alexander "Katy" Easterday was an American football and basketball player, track and field athlete, coach, college athletics administrator, and dentist. He played at the halfback position for the Pittsburgh Panthers football teams from 1917 to 1918 and was selected as an All-American in 1918...
  
  , Pittsburgh (TM-1)
• Flowers, Georgia Tech (WC-2 [fb]; TM-2)
• Skip Gougler
  Skip Gougler
  Roscoe A. "Skip" Gougler was an American football player and coach, dentist and professor of dentistry. He played at the halfback and quarterback positions for the Pitt Panthers football teams from 1915-1918. He was selected as a second-team All-American in 1918...
  
  , Pittsburgh (TM-2)
• Frisch, Fordham (WC-2)
• Eckberg, Minnesota (WC-3)
• Kelley, Rutgers (WC-3)

Fullbacks

• Frank Steketee
  Frank Steketee
  Frank W. Steketee was an All American football halfback and fullback who played with the University of Michigan Wolverines in 1918, 1920, and 1921...
  
  , Michigan (WC-1; TM-2)
• George McLaren, Pittsburgh (WC-2 [hb]; MS; TM-1)
• Butler, Navy (WC-3)