String theory
Ed Witten explains string theory, 2 = 1
Posts  1 - 7  of  7
boshito
Proof that 2 = 1
__________________

Let, a = b + c

2a = a + b + c

2a - 2b = a - b + c

2a - 2b - 2c = a - b - c

2(a - b - c) = 1(a - b - c)

2 = 1
replied to:  boshito
macsking
Replied to:  Proof that 2 = 1 __________________ Let, a = b...
A novel, but convoluted way, of performing this stunt - i.e. obtaining a spurious result by including the "illegal" operation of dividing by zero (a-b-c). However, my limited mathematical brain believes the experts in string theory. I have never seen any argument to discredit the theory on the grounds of using illegal (illogical) operations. That is, I believe that it is mathematically rigorous and valid.

However, I can subscribe to the idea that the limit of x/a, as "a" approaches zero is infinity, a completely, utterly, frustratingly incomprehensible result. I put string theory, and certainly quantum physics, in the same basket. My mind can't cope with the concept, but the reality is there in the maths.

I gain some consolation that the great Richard Feynman confessed ". . . .I don't understand it (QED)but nobody does".

So if the maths works then it comes down to "if you don't understand it, just accept it".
replied to:  boshito
yuvrajhanspal
Replied to:  Proof that 2 = 1 __________________ Let, a = b...
My friend, you are trying to divide by 0 !!
replied to:  boshito
TruthandJustice
Replied to:  Proof that 2 = 1 __________________ Let, a = b...
SORRY I AM NOT AS SMART AS YOU BUT
1. A=B+C I AGREE
2. 2A = A+B+C

IF YOU MULTIPLY Ax2 =2A

IF YOU MULTIPLY SIDE 1 OF EQATION THEN YOU MULTIPLY SIDE 2 BY THE SAME # 2= 2A= B+C X(2)= 2B + 2C

I MAY BE WRONG SO BE PATIENT AN EDUCATE ME IF YOU ARE GOING TO BE CONDESCENDING DO NOT BOTHER THANKS
replied to:  macsking
TruthandJustice
Replied to:  A novel, but convoluted way, of performing this stunt - i.e....
I AGREE AND I AM VERY IMPRESSED BY THE SIMPLE YET LOGICAL RESPONSE THANK YOU, PLEZ READ MY ??? ABOVE WHERE I DO NOT AGREE WITH THE THEOREM BUT IF I AM WRONG JUST SHOW ME THANKS DOC
replied to:  macsking
TruthandJustice
Replied to:  A novel, but convoluted way, of performing this stunt - i.e....
I AGREE AND I AM VERY IMPRESSED BY THE SIMPLE YET LOGICAL RESPONSE THANK YOU PLEZ READ MY ??? ABOVE WHERE I DO NOT AGREE WITH THE THEOREM BUT IF I AM WRONG JUST SHOW ME THANKS DOC
replied to:  TruthandJustice
macsking
Replied to:  I AGREE AND I AM VERY IMPRESSED BY THE SIMPLE YET...
If a = b + c, then a-b-c = zero
Dividing by zero is a meaningless,illegal operation.